YouTube is Removing Videos - Are You Affected?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Wow. Disneycartoys got their channel terminated. I think another one kd their channels too. Kind of makes sense i guess, since they were the original spiderman and elsa. Didnt think their channel was that bad but i havent checked out all their vids.

Just noticed this as well. They had changed to Sandaroo Kids recently. I think what caught them was the Trolls videos where they encouraged teen pregnancy and robbing banks. I stopped allowing my child to watch her channel after I heard that playing in the background about 6 months ago.
 
Wow, she basically created the kids entertainment/toy play genre.

I hadn't checked out her channel in a long time, but she *always* had pregnancy play. I don't know about her recent stuff, but before it was just like Mommy + baby play. I'm personally not sure how I feel about pregnancy being depicted (something we NEVER did), but what I mean is that kids have siblings. So it seems like a normal part of life; though I realize that everyone's sensitivity to this subject is different.

Was she *actually* encouraging "teen pregnancy" or simply having story-lines in which a parent-type figure is pregnant?

I'm super surprised that she would be deleted and not given the chance to clean up her channel, like other big channels were able to do. For example, DCTC was allowed to clean their channel first. I mean, even RyanToysReview pulled down half a billion views but they're still around.
 
Wow, she basically created the kids entertainment/toy play genre.

I hadn't checked out her channel in a long time, but she *always* had pregnancy play. I don't know about her recent stuff, but before it was just like Mommy + baby play. I'm personally not sure how I feel about pregnancy being depicted (something we NEVER did), but what I mean is that kids have siblings. So it seems like a normal part of life; though I realize that everyone's sensitivity to this subject is different.

Was she *actually* encouraging "teen pregnancy" or simply having story-lines in which a parent-type figure is pregnant?

I'm super surprised that she would be deleted and not given the chance to clean up her channel, like other big channels were able to do. For example, DCTC was allowed to clean their channel first. I mean, even RyanToysReview pulled down half a billion views but they're still around.

Well here is one example that I find inappropriate and unacceptable. youtube.com/watch?v=AMy3llWek6U
There is another one where they do an armed bank robbery.
 
Wow, she basically created the kids entertainment/toy play genre.

I hadn't checked out her channel in a long time, but she *always* had pregnancy play. I don't know about her recent stuff, but before it was just like Mommy + baby play. I'm personally not sure how I feel about pregnancy being depicted (something we NEVER did), but what I mean is that kids have siblings. So it seems like a normal part of life; though I realize that everyone's sensitivity to this subject is different.

Was she *actually* encouraging "teen pregnancy" or simply having story-lines in which a parent-type figure is pregnant?

I'm super surprised that she would be deleted and not given the chance to clean up her channel, like other big channels were able to do. For example, DCTC was allowed to clean their channel first. I mean, even RyanToysReview pulled down half a billion views but they're still around.
Disneycartoys is owned by same people as dctc. They all run a bunch of channels.
I just learned something new going down the rabbit hole. If you google “disneycartoys” one of the first videos recommend is “disneycartoys and alltoycollector twins...”. I thought disneycartoys mom and alltoycollector mom were the same person. Didnt know they were twins! One of the dctc channels has another woman’s face but i think theyre all related. They were able to keep their other channels for the most part.

Edit: i was wrong about dctc being same as disneycartoys
 
Last edited:
Disneycartoys is owned by same people as dctc. They all run a bunch of channels.
I just learned something new going down the rabbit hole. If you google “disneycartoys” one of the first videos recommend is “disneycartoys and alltoycollector twins...”. I thought disneycartoys mom and alltoycollector mom were the same person. Didnt know they were twins! One of the dctc channels has another woman’s face but i think theyre all related. They were able to keep their other channels for the most part.

DCTC is a group that is not related to Sandra.

Sandra is DisneyCarToys and alltoycollector and toysreviewtoys are all related family members

youtube.wikia.com/wiki/DisneyCarToys
 
DCTC is a group that is not related to Sandra.

Sandra is DisneyCarToys and alltoycollector and toysreviewtoys are all related family members

youtube.wikia.com/wiki/DisneyCarToys

Whops! My bad. Back when they were called disney car toys club and then changed their name to dctc i got them mixed up with disneycartoys. Thought they were the same. So that explains why the channel has a different person lol. Too many disney cars channels floating around.
 
Has anyone noticed a significant decrease in ad revenue when a video is being viewed heavily by viewers outside the US? Does your channel get most of their traffic from non-us viewers? It seems like channels that feature Asian stars tend to have more viewers. I am assuming this means the majority of their traffic comes from Asian countries, but it would also seem that they receive less money per 1,000 views. Can anyone confirm this? I once had a video viewed 4 million times that was only getting around 1$ per 1,000 views. Every other video that exceeded one million views performed a lot better. I then realized that this video getting a lower ad rate was primarily being watched by non-us viewers.[DOUBLEPOST=1512590434,1512585658][/DOUBLEPOST]Disneycartoys has been reinstated. Interesting move by Youtube.
 
Youtube's global head of family and learning has penned an open letter to all kids channel creators. Since the aim is for the message to be circulated as widely as possible, I have reproduced the letter in its entirety below.

The source is here: http://kidscreen.com/2017/12/07/op-ed-dear-youtube-family-creator-community/

______________________

Dear YouTube family creator community,

We love what you do. We love your creativity, innovation and the inspiration that you provide to kids and families. Since YouTube launched over a decade ago, it has given voice to a new generation of creators. And since YouTube Kids launched almost three years ago, we’ve been so excited by the creativity of the enriching content you’ve created. Whether your videos enrich through science experiments, inspire through family vlogs, or entertain with storytelling, what you have built has driven joy and curiosity at scale.

In the last few weeks, there’s been a lot of reports about content masquerading as family-friendly on YouTube and concern among some family creators about changes on the platform, so I wanted to take some time to explain what we are working on and to let you know—we hear you and we are listening. While we can’t talk with everyone, we are actively engaged with creators, educators, family experts, trusted partners and flaggers, influencers and more to get this constantly evolving landscape right, and will continue to expand that effort.

Content masquerading as family-friendly on YouTube, a small amount of which has appeared in YouTube Kids, is an issue that we have been deeply focused on. Let me be clear in stating that content that deceives or harms families is absolutely unacceptable and to combat this content we needed to take significant action. We have clear policies against these videos and we enforce them aggressively. In the past week alone, we have terminated hundreds of accounts and over 150,000 videos that have violated these policies. Beyond that, we have removed ads from over two million videos and over 50,000 channels that masquerade as family-friendly to reduce the incentive to produce this content.

These actions are broad and sweeping because this is an area that is absolutely non-negotiable to us: We must stop the bad actors and the impact they have on the broader creator community. We’re trying hard not to make mistakes—but we know our systems aren’t perfect and we apologize for that. We know that some of you feel like you may be getting caught in the broader net of our actions, and have questions about what works and what doesn’t work on the platform. We know you need more clarity, and as soon as we can, we pledge to provide it.

For months we have been working on a comprehensive guide of best practices for creators in this space. We know sometimes the lines are blurred when it comes to the do’s and don’ts of creating family content, but we’re here to help and show you what type of content is eligible for consideration in the YouTube Kids app. This extensive guide will be available soon as a first step in what we hope will continue to be an ongoing dialogue about how to create content for YouTube Kids.

Almost three years ago, when we launched YouTube Kids, we used these exact words: “Family entertainment brings us all together, taking the experience, knowledge and creativity of one generation and turning it into the fuel that inspires another. You’re helping to educate the next generation of doctors, artists, explorers and scientists. Family entertainment, these stories, move us all forward.”

These words have never been truer, especially today.

As always, thank you for your feedback, patience and support over the coming months. Stay tuned and we’ll stay in touch. Thank you.

Malik Ducard
Global Head of Family and Learning
YouTube

(Source: http://kidscreen.com/2017/12/07/op-ed-dear-youtube-family-creator-community/)
______________________________
 
Hi this is Tritons father I have noticed the crack down on children’s channels as of late. It seems that only material with questionable content is being hit currently. Content that can be seen as vulgar or inappropriate! Just one example Is talking about things like “poo” some people aren’t comfortable with their kids being exposed to these things and it should be understandable. Often times kids repeat and are or copy what they hear/see especially from other kids they look up to, kids on these channels. There is a thin line and not all people raise their kids the same way or see things the same, so that line is ever changing. I say if you think it’s appropriate for your kids and the majority it should be safe. I personally am not judging anyone who creates videos with the content that may fall into the grey area, but we as the parents all have to be aware of our children’s audience, other children, regardless of what we think is wrong or right for our own! Now perhaps some of this content is being hit in error as well, who’s to say your content is or isn’t appropriate or if it does or doesn’t fall into the grey area? Certainly not me, I’m just giving my opinion on the topic
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top