Symphonious7's BRUTAL Reviews

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hey I need to acknowledge something. I became waaaay overly defensive when Aaron E said what he said, that was very childish of me. I'm not saying anything about what he said in the first place or anything like that I can only speak for myself, but I became extremely overly defensive, and that was uncool of me. Needed to be said.
 
Hey Symphonious7, would you mind reviewing my music video? I'm the producer and director.

Many Thanks

JC
Electric Slave Productions
www.electric-slave.com
In essence this was fantastic. The idea itself is fantastic, the way it was shot was amazing, the idea was awesome. It fell short for me in the fact that by somewhere between 2 and 3 minutes I was feeling over saturated with the idea. I felt I'd seen enough things flying and crashing in slow mo at that point and wanted it to open up into something new. Like in my mind I was envisioning suddenly the guy starts dancing in slow motion or something using people instead of objects. It just felt like it didn't keep building, it stayed doing the same thing it began doing.

But as a whole and as an idea, I thought it was really amazing. The song itself is not my favorite, it's not bad, but I don't think it's interesting enough as an instrumental to really carry the idea without something visually stunning. If it had vocals it might be a different story. Since this was a mixed review I'll rate it, I'd give it a 7 out of 10.
 
Feel free to check our ours, I must warn you though, its a gaming channel though, but I find its more interesting than the norm, also in the near future we will be putting up a handful of new series that have nothing to do with video games.
 
In essence this was fantastic. The idea itself is fantastic, the way it was shot was amazing, the idea was awesome. It fell short for me in the fact that by somewhere between 2 and 3 minutes I was feeling over saturated with the idea. I felt I'd seen enough things flying and crashing in slow mo at that point and wanted it to open up into something new. Like in my mind I was envisioning suddenly the guy starts dancing in slow motion or something using people instead of objects. It just felt like it didn't keep building, it stayed doing the same thing it began doing.

But as a whole and as an idea, I thought it was really amazing. The song itself is not my favorite, it's not bad, but I don't think it's interesting enough as an instrumental to really carry the idea without something visually stunning. If it had vocals it might be a different story. Since this was a mixed review I'll rate it, I'd give it a 7 out of 10.


Thanks for the excellent review man, I appreciate your honesty.

JC
Electric Slave Productions
 
Thats an ignorent and elitist way of looking at things imo.

Everything is the same as eveything if you think like that. All vlogs are the same (they all talk about themselfs like they are important) all gameplay vids are the same (they all play games and talk) all comady sketchs are the same (they all try to make you laugh) all cover songs are the same (they all sing someone elses song) all singers atre the same (They just play an instrument and sing a songthey worte), you have a very elitist view imo.

what I do requires just as much talent as what you do mate, its just a different genre. I dont just play a game... I play a game at a very high level and also do turotials and tips to help other people get better too.

I have people all the time messageing me thanking me because I have helped them get better. Just because you dont care for games alot of the population does. People dont just play for fun they play to better themselfs to learn a new skill. Just because its digital and not physical doesnt make them lower then you lol

My review was honest, but it was from an elitist, ignorent mouth, I reviewed the reviewer ;)
When you play a game at a "high level", all you've really completed is the memorization of the maze. I know we're all out for a bit of cheese, but you have it here with your broad scathing generalizations of everything being the same as everything. Writing material that must be performed versus performing material that was designed and developed to be played exactly as you've demonstrated aren't comprable. Being an entertainer at the same time, with astounding narrative atop the footage that the million dollars made, tested, and promoted might put you into the same category. But there is nothing elitist about segregating screen record footage (fancy a** video piracy) from filmmakers (capturing any performing artist on tape) What you have isn't talent, it's practice. There is no such thing as talent in video games, there is practice and execution of design. The talent is on the production side, where all of these potential tasks are thought out for you to discover, but the discovery isn't a talent, it's an investment of time and a reward of pattern recognition and motor reflexes.[DOUBLEPOST=1343284840][/DOUBLEPOST]
apology accepted, maybe change the title to brutal opinions or honest opinions or somthing. Because everyone can have an opinion.
Opinions are offered without request. Example: Street Fighter can be played as well by the monkey of the day as it can by a trained expert. Watching your videos as a filmmaker feels very much the same as the sensation you experience when you lose two rounds to a button masher. I can hear your protests at how that never happens, it happens as often as Let's Play videos are watchable. That's my opinion, you didn't ask for it. I'm being an elitist. Symph was doing what you requested of him, against his threads guidelines at that, a favor. So chin up controller chimp, you can make something other people can watch if you try.
 
When you play a game at a "high level", all you've really completed is the memorization of the maze. I know we're all out for a bit of cheese, but you have it here with your broad scathing generalizations of everything being the same as everything. Writing material that must be performed versus performing material that was designed and developed to be played exactly as you've demonstrated aren't comprable. Being an entertainer at the same time, with astounding narrative atop the footage that the million dollars made, tested, and promoted might put you into the same category. But there is nothing elitist about segregating screen record footage (fancy a** video piracy) from filmmakers (capturing any performing artist on tape) What you have isn't talent, it's practice. There is no such thing as talent in video games, there is practice and execution of design. The talent is on the production side, where all of these potential tasks are thought out for you to discover, but the discovery isn't a talent, it's an investment of time and a reward of pattern recognition and motor reflexes.[DOUBLEPOST=1343284840][/DOUBLEPOST]
Opinions are offered without request. Example: Street Fighter can be played as well by the monkey of the day as it can by a trained expert. Watching your videos as a filmmaker feels very much the same as the sensation you experience when you lose two rounds to a button masher. I can hear your protests at how that never happens, it happens as often as Let's Play videos are watchable. That's my opinion, you didn't ask for it. I'm being an elitist. Symph was doing what you requested of him, against his threads guidelines at that, a favor. So chin up controller chimp, you can make something other people can watch if you try.

What a suprise another guy who doesnt do video games but seems to know everything about them. You are not better then me man. Just coz you like to be in front of a camera and like to act. Not suprised there is another elitist person thoiugh, (but Symphonious7 at least apolgysed, you're just a delluded *****)

Also your a guy just in it for the money - opens a shop at 1k subs with 100 views each vid lol f*****g pathetic

I dont care for people like you. I do my youtube for my fans you jsut want money, hf with that you untalented delluded person. You cant even make your own character up lol. Copy paste of jonny depps pirate character lol pathetic. Get some talent you Z movie actor

I act infront of a camera therefore im amazing (although no1 hardely watches my s**t) lol

$24 for this s**t? http://www.cafepress.com/ guerrilla_day_project_grown_up_sippy_cup,655835352?utm_medium=affiliate&utm_source=youtube

lol

Your graphics and brand is f*****g horrible
 
What a suprise another guy who doesnt do video games but seems to know everything about them. You are not better then me man. Just coz you like to be in front of a camera and like to act. Not suprised there is another elitist person thoiugh, (but Symphonious7 at least apolgysed, you're just a delluded *****)

Also your a guy just in it for the money - opens a shop at 1k subs with 100 views each vid lol f*****g pathetic

I dont care for people like you. I do my youtube for my fans you jsut want money, hf with that you untalented delluded person. You cant even make your own character up lol. Copy paste of jonny depps pirate character lol pathetic. Get some talent you Z movie actor

I act infront of a camera therefore im amazing (although no1 hardely watches my s**t) lol

$24 for this s**t? http://www.cafepress.com/ guerrilla_day_project_grown_up_sippy_cup,655835352?utm_medium=affiliate&utm_source=youtube

lol

Your graphics and brand is f*****g horrible

You don't deserve an apology. You're the one that's got something to be embarrassed about.
In it for what money? Are you kidding? Cause your ignorance is adorable.
Shops opened automatically I think we had 600 subs at the time, we didn't even ask for the tab.
$24 for the "Grown Up Sippy Cup". Exactly nuts for brains. If YouTube gave you a silly store wouldn't you inflate the price of something as sellout as a coffee mug if you wanted to discourage viewers from purchasing it. I forgot wait your concept of economics comes from point systems.
Those graphics are cooler than your wet dreams.
You don't have fans. TRue.
You don't have a brand. TRue.
Make something, I mean seriously anything that you make, it can be a macaroni necklace
Nevermind you PreTalent Hack GTFO. It's impossible for you to see how useless you are.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top