Oh god Google... what have you done?

[WolfWraith]

I don't see how this would work for vloggers. What could I claim really?

Currently at this stage nothing as Shane pointed us to a post made by Creative Nation which basically says it's just giving the creators the ability to control the policy themselves, this actually means more money for Content Creators since the shifty networks can no longer control the policies.[DOUBLEPOST=1389225046,1389225019][/DOUBLEPOST]

Why not punish the ones who abuse the system? Remove their partnership and/or YouTube account or remove their ability to monetize videos. Seems like a good idea.

I'd much rather they not put a system that can be abused in the first place.

 

[rickyfromkingston]

i have this 1on a few of my channels i tryed it out on 2 channels i dont care about i had a video on 1 witch is a year old and i uploaded the same video on anther one and tryed the content id it flaged my video on my other channle that was uploaded a year ago and its a gaming video so this is BAD if that is how it works :/ the older video should of not got content id

 

[WolfWraith]

i have this 1on a few of my channels i tryed it out on 2 channels i dont care about i had a video on 1 witch is a year old and i uploaded the same video on anther one and tryed the content id it flaged my video on my other channle that was uploaded a year ago and its a gaming video so this is BAD if that is how it works :/ the older video should of not got content id

Did it match a specific point or the entire video?

 

[Kleineganz]

https://twitter.com/EdgeTalks/status/420873373778837504

Is this new? Wtf is Google doing?

I think you still have to apply to the Content ID system before you get that option (I certainly don't see it).

 

[Franklin]

I like this addition if it made properly. Hopefully this will stop or limit false video claims. That is a serious problem on YouTube. This can add protection for smaller channels like myself.

 

[Jak]

LOL. Youtube be tripping. As I sit and think about it...the chances of someone claiming my content is mad slim so for NOW...its all good (in my head atleast.)

 

[Gabriel]

Hopefully this will stop or limit false video claims. That is a serious problem on YouTube.

The invalid claims most of the time come from batch form uploads (hundreds & hundreds) of reference files to CMS, files that shouldn't be included in the first place end up in the batch and the content owner usually will never notice until disputes start coming in. While I'm not sticking up for the companies that abuse the system, I do acknowledge most of the time they don't know about false claiming arising until it's brought to their attention - though, it's poor internal management to not check all your reference files before upload.

Also, this [Content ID claiming on youtube.com] has always been available to those the network enabled CID scanning on their channel. From what it looks like, this option is only enabled by default for "managed" partners. You [the network] wouldn't put a partner on managed if they didn't own all their content so.. no false claims should come up.