Which thumbnail is better?

[AllVisuals4U]

Hi there,

I'm planning to give my thumbnails an upgrade. I'm pretty happy with the current ones, but i was asking myself or a clean design will attract more viewers. So here's the question: which thumbnail do you like more? The old ones with the red and green stripe along the whole thumbnail or the new clean ones with the red and green square at the left top? Looking forward to your answers!

 

[Gate of Theories]

Cool designs

 

[UhoohExtra]

Hey there the first 2 designs looked like white noise to me and may get looked over without people noticing - too grey etc. The very last one stood out the most as being the most 'clickable'. All were well made though. You could always rotate them once a week to see which works best for you.

 

[AllVisuals4U]

Thank you for the answers! I decided to go for the new ones.
Think it's a good evolution of the old thumbnails.

 

[DapperDanVlogs]

the last one is the best to me. a photo of the actual card would go a long way though