While I agree with paragraph 4 of your post I have to say your whole post entirely was very frustrating to read.
Not everything should be hugs and kisses. Reality checks are valuable too.
I understand your analysis of dissecting the popular YouTuber's choices in variety, because it seems that most of them today create these awful "variety" videos just to spew crappy content out into the world to stay relevant.
That is another bad reason why they do so.
It seems though that you have some personal "vendetta" with the more popular YouTube makers...
Hardly.
...and are taking it out on these new creators. They came to you seeking answers and guidance and instead of trying to positively provide them with the information they can use to better themselves, you came at them with brutal opinions.
I've been a marketer for over three decades. Sometimes the best thing I can give clients is a reality check and not hugs and kisses. Brantman19 asked my opinion about the issue ("What's your take on...") and I gave it.
The beauty of Youtube is that it's NOT television, we DON'T have the restrictions of having to stick to a script, or keep a cohesive story flowing, as creators we can do whatever the heck we want to do!
Sorry, I was trying to help them succeed and not baby them. It is a fantasy to think YouTube is different, that conventions of other forms of entertainment don't apply to it, that YouTube somehow can violate core marketing principles, and that you can do whatever you want and succeed. Yes, you can do whatever you want but if you want to succeed, there's actual ways that have been shown to work. I mean you do realize you just made that statement in a forum titled "Strategies and Technique Advice", right? And YouTube is very much like TV in its development stages. Read up on the history of TV and YouTube and you'll see a lot of parallels.
With that being said, you're correct in that it's very good to understand marketing if you're trying to make it far in the world of YouTube, but it's definitely not going to get you to the top.
I have never read or heard of a SINGLE successful YouTuber who ever said such a thing. Instead, I have read and heard of ones that work very hard to market their channels to YouTube, social media, and the general public. If you know of a successful YouTuber that just stumbled their way to success on YouTube, please tell me who they are. Seriously, I would really like to know.
YouTube is not about formula's and strategies, it's about being human and presenting your creations to the world.
Again, you're posting that statement in a forum titled "Strategies and Technique Advice". Every successful YouTuber who I have heard talk, read, or watched has ALWAYS talked about the formulas and strategies they've have used to get to the top. Frederator even put out a book titled "The 10 YouTube Commandments". Tim Schmoyer's "Video Creators" YouTube channel is all about what works and what doesn't.
Look at Pewdiepie, it wasn't business strategies that got him to the top.
Then you haven't researched PewDiePie much or listen to many interviews of him where he talks about how hard he works at making his channel a success, that he has worked out a strategy that has proven very successful for him (that so far he hasn't publicly revealed), and how others analyze what he's done and are trying to copy it.
And now you insult me when I encourage new YouTubers to read a SINGLE introductory book on marketing.[DOUBLEPOST=1443056059,1443055757][/DOUBLEPOST]
I don't mind critisism, but u kind of said my channel is not going to suceed which wasn't necessary
No, I didn't. Quote me. I did give advice about how it might be done better and why I think so. That is quite different than what you're accusing me of. That you read more into what I wrote than what is there ("u kind of said") is not my problem.