Screwed? | A quick end to my YT career| Please help [SOLVED]

Note that YouTube will also terminate the new channel when they find out that you were previously terminated.
Yh this is unfortunate even I didn't know this but it's written here (https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2802168?hl=en-GB). This guy shows you how you can appeal your termination and try to negotiate with google/youtube since they now have an appeal form you can fill out on that support page. HOWEVER this does not mean that you'll get it back.
 
Yh this is unfortunate even I didn't know this but it's written here (). This guy shows you how you can appeal your termination and try to negotiate with google/youtube since they now have an appeal form you can fill out on that support page. HOWEVER this does not mean that you'll get it back.
Oh, I did not know that, well hopefully they can get it sorted out, losing a new channel because of unkown issues and unresolved issues on an old channel would suck...
 
Well...if you do a google search for your channel url you will come across some sites that seem very spammy. While your video or channel itself wasn't embedded on those sites, your URL was listed in the description of one of your friends (Mudder?) who has videos on several of those sites. My guess is that you received traffic from those sites, Youtube's algorithms picked up on it and saw the traffic as a gross violation of their spam policy. Here, check out this link:

Your URL even appears on a site that has had it's videos removed for violation of Adsense's TOS. Again, I'm not saying you put it there, but your channel URL appears on those pages.

For example:

That's the google cache of a page that your channel link appears on 4 times. That's a strange looking page and certainly seems spammy to me. Youtube could easily consider traffic from sites like that spam traffic.

That's just my guess. Good luck with your appeal (if you haven't appealed already). Before you appeal, make sure you find out specifically the nature of the infraction. They often will tell you which section of code your channel violated if you ask them. Secondly, you'll likely have hardly any luck with a "I have no idea what happened" defense. You need to tell them that you realize what the problem was and that you've taken steps to rectify that problem and it won't be an issue moving forward. For example, if you can determine that what I said might be the problem was actually the problem, you could say "Well, I found out recently that my friend, in an attempt to help me, placed my link in his video descriptions. He then, without my knowledge, posted his videos on various sites that seem less than legitimate. I've spoken with him and he removed all of my links from his videos. This will not be a problem in the future, I can assure you. If you could reinstate my account I would appreciate it as I take Youtube seriously and work very hard on my channel. Thank you". That's your only chance at reinstatement and even then it's a longshot. Saying "I don't know what happened, I didn't do anything wrong" never works.

Good luck.

Great work detective. Hope you get to the root of the problem and it is reversible.
 
If it said misleading content then u were reported and when they looked into it then u had titles that were just misleading which is an "illegal" way to get viewers. And if it said for gaming i dont know
 
The rules for gaming videos are quite... blurry, for lack of a better term.

OK, so this is how it works. You're allowed to do gaming videos provided they meet this criteria:
1) You're educating people, for example, showing them how to play the game, how to reach a certain location, how to find an easter egg, glitch, whatever.
2) If you're critically analysing the game, for example, if you were reviewing a game.
3) If you were talking about in-game related discussions.

However, you start infringing upon copyright when you start playing games, recording them but talking about what your nan cooked your for dinner.

You'll be breaching community guidelines if you just play the game with no commentary or no commentary to do with the game whatsoever.

Links aren't allowed so Google YouTube Gaming Video Guidelines << Have a look at that.
Also, in the booklets that come with non-pirated games, it will have the licence (usually on the first page or the last page) and it can ALWAYS be found on a developers website and is often on the back of game cases. If the licence allows you to use the game commercially, then providing you meet the licence conditions, YouTube's community guidelines shouldn't really come into it provided it isn't causing detriment to YouTube as a community itself.

"Without the appropriate license from the publisher, use of video game or software user interface must be minimal. Video game content may be monetized if the associated step-by-step commentary is strictly tied to the live action being shown and provides instructional or educational value.

Videos simply showing a user playing a video game or the use of software for extended periods of time may not be accepted for monetization."

Also, see this video regarding copyright at the bottom of the page.

I think that what you've probably done is played the game for a while with no commentary or without appropriate commentary. The likelihood of you getting your account reinstated is minimal but to be honest, if you're paying for exposure, then once the advertising campaign is over, you'll go back to normal. If you've paid for advertising and only gained 10 subscribers, well... that's very worrying. You should focus on creating better content that those few people who do see it will share it. That's how you do well on YouTube, not by paying your way through - seems you want to earn cash from YouTube so by paying to earn that cash completely defeats the purpose.

YouTube would have caught you out because you wanted to advertise your video, I daresay a developer who worked for the game company you were playing, seen the advert and reported you to YouTube for infringement.

It sucks but if you don't understand the copyright laws, you should either seek legal advice which will be money better spent than on advertising or you can play it by ear, like you have done, and risk everything falling apart.
Don't worry, I know the feeling. I'm debating whether to join an MCN so I have the support from them. But then I think Well, I could just learn the copyright laws for myself, which is what I am doing.

Hopefully, you'll be able to get the suspension lifted. Explain you've fully reviewed the community guidelines. Check in your Video Manager to see what videos have monetisation turned off (I bet it'll be the one you advertised or a game made by the developers of the game you made an advertisement for). Explain that you are happy to delete the videos which infringe on copyright and that you will ensure you fully understand the licences associated with games, as well as the copyright laws and YouTube community guidelines and that you're very sorry and it won't happen again.

It might also be worth contacting the developers and apologising, just say you didn't know and ask them if it is OK to use their games in future videos. If they say yes, then you're good to go and can do as you please (within reason, I guess) with footage of their gameplay.

I really hope this helps. Good luck with your channel and if it doesn't take off, let me give you this advice:

You should be on YouTube because you enjoy it, not ready to throw it in simply because you can't monetise videos or had a hiccup with your account. If you show Google you're passionate and willing to learn the rules, they'll want you on their platform. Otherwise, well, there's always Twitch and Vimeo and a lot of other video sharing sites. You should be in it because you enjoy it, not for the money. Viewers can see straight through fakery. Trust me.:)
 
A friend of mine had this issue after he dumped some chick that worked for google. I think she pulled some strings to suspend his account.
 
I think that what you've probably done is played the game for a while with no commentary or without appropriate commentary.
The reason they gave was
"This account has been suspended due to multiple or severe violations of YouTube's policy against spam, gaming, misleading content, or other Terms of Service violations."
Most of the time that means that they didn't like the traffic that was going to his channel/videos. The other part of the time it means he was putting keywords in his description or using misleading thumbnails or titles. I've checked his videos that are cached on Google and they didn't have anything like that, so it's most likely the traffic.
The likelihood of you getting your account reinstated is minimal
It's pretty much zero now. He's appealed (probably a poorly crafted appeal) and has been rejected.
 
I do want to point out that Valve the company that makes one of the games that he does play has an open policy as far as recording game footage. Here is what their site said:


Valve Video Policy
We encourage our users to make videos using Valve game content, such as playthrough or instruction videos or SFM movies. We are fine with publishing these videos to your website or YouTube or similar video sharing services. We're not fine with taking assets from our games (e.g. voice, music, items) and distributing those separately.

Use of our content in videos must be non-commercial. By that we mean you can't charge users to view or access your videos. You also can't sell or license your videos to others for a payment of any kind.

You are free to monetize your videos via the YouTube partner program and similar programs on other video sharing sites. Please don't ask us to write YouTube and tell them its fine with us to post a particular video using Valve content. It's not possible to respond to each such request. Point them to this page.

Of course this policy applies only to Valve content. If you include someone else's content in your video, such as music, you will have to get permission from the owner."

won't let me post the link to where i got the info, but just google, valve video policy and it's the first link.

So I don't think recording CS:GO was an issue at all, unless it was a youtube policy that may have caused his suspension.
 
Back
Top