anyone needs their channel reviewed? [HAS DELAY]

Hey check out my channel.
The Channel Trailer is fine. Video doesn't matter as long as you pick one.
Thanks man!

reviewed: herobrine's mansion pt.2
+
Co-op is always good, makes the interaction between you guys interesting
You guys are consistently talking
The quality is alright
The dude with the real high pitched voice is heard well most of the time
-
You asked for a drum roll nearly the entire first minute but nothing happened when they did, which makes it quite an odd intro
Sometimes it gets difficult to understand what you guys are saying, partially because of the audio quality and partially because of eachother (especially the lower pitched dude is difficult to hear)
you didn't put any annotations at the end.

now quickly a + bout your channel trailer, well timed with the text!
all i all tho theres still a lot of room for improvement especially concerning the intros to your videos.

Hello,
I am a fairly new Youtuber,
Here is my latest decent (in my opinon) video that I have uploaded
I thank you in advance for rating my video/channel.

First off- thanks for putting in the effort to actually tell something about yourself c:
Alright lets see

+
channel:I love the song in the channel trailer, combined with the unnecessary violence in the games it makes it humorous to watch
vid:
Good voice in the intro
clear intro
'aliens and stuff' is probably one the best descriptions of a game
I dont have a clue how the gamemode works but you seem to be doing pretty good
-
channel: at around 30 sec in your channel trailer you start talking, but it's very hard to understand. It would be preferable to either leave the talking out or make it louder so it can be heard.
vid:
'i appeared not interested' - If you need to say that you know something can be improved.
one of your friends is quite difficult to hear.
As you've said, try put more expression into it. It was too long for me to watch in its entirety, but i didn't hear anyone laughing or making jokes.

So i guess you've got the basics, now you should try to practice a lot on your commentating skills.
EDIT: at 14:25 i spotted expression and someone laughing, definitely entertaining but you should try to keep it a bit consistent throughout the video
 
Review mine? Be brutally honest :p

Alright ill try c: as you didnt put in a video tho, ill only review your channel trailer.
actually cuz that wasnt that much.. lemme review ragemart thing too
+
clear
says pretty much everything you do i suppose
ragemart vid:
your voice is good, clear and understandable
the talking in the game is pretty good
-
'you haven't subscribed to me yet' - I don't know why, but this makes me reluctant to sub, as it basically means you expect me to in the future (good if you're really confident, but can also seem a bit overconfi)
ragemart vid:
the intro is understandable, but the first jokes come after 40 seconds - try using a joke in the beginning or something to pull viewers in
the video is pretty long, maybe too long.
Background music would've been nice

- You have comedic talent, but theres quite some improv points.

It would be cool if you would review one of our videos :)
Don't need to bother with the channel trailer, as it's just the first episode in our latest series :p]

Alright lets see, as you guys suggested i'll only review the video
+
the introduction is adorable, very much fun to hear.
all of your voices are clearly heard, good to follow
the entire lets-play is full of laughter and such, very entertaining
your accents are fascinating
-
co-operative videos with 3 people can become a bit difficult as it gets hard to know who is talking (for new viewers)
as you've said, its not very focused at the audience, but i personally have trouble doing that in co-ops so i'm not very sure how to help there :/
after you beat the level you repeated a part? with music? Maybe it's something you guys do as a sort of unique thing, but i don't really understand what it's for
The actual outro was 7 seconds or so, which is a bit short for me as a viewer to decide which of the four choices you gave i should click.
^ adding to the last two, your outro doesn't say much about you, it's good that there is an outro of sorts, but i believe if you would've just pot a clip of you guys saying 'bye guys, till next time' or anything like that, it'd have been a more logical ending.

Heh. looking at what i wrote it seems as if i found it bad because of the big amount of -'s, but seriously, you guys are really entertaining and seem like cool people to hang out with. Your video seems professional, but maybe your outro is a bit too vague.
anyway, was a pleasure to review you guys c:

I'd like a review if you get at chance, Be a honest as you need to be!]

sorry i posted this reply before reviewing you, misclick there. lets do that

+
channel trailer:
very good explanation of your channel in a comedic way, i like it
awesome use of background music
funny ending c:
video:
good hook into the video by giving such a tweet before the intro
'it was just like a skeleton in the class, and nobody knew' <- thats an amazing quote cx
your idea of reading tweets and criticizing them is definitely good, funny to see and watch you make fun of them tbh.
awesome outro
-
channel trailer:
You talk a bit slow, can be a good thing, but in this case i (personally) would prefer you talking a bit quicker and maybe more energetic. (i know thats not always possible, but i'd think it would improve as far as thats possible)
video:
again, you talk a bit slow, maybe take a bit too slow pauses which make it very easy to follow but a bit less entertaining. i know it's difficult to change but it is a consistent thing throughout the video, so it could definitely be beneficial for the entertainment value of the video.
You seem to have a lack of expression in the video, a possible tip is to attempt hyping yourself up, idk what you can get hyped about but it might work.
Well.. you seemed like you were about to cry at the end of the video. Might've just been me, and i don't mean anything bad by saying it, but i dont think it's good to get actually emotional in the video, unless it's your goal to do so (when screaming 'leave Britney alone' its alright to be emotional). <- and about the low self-esteem thing, i know how you feel, but it seems a bit... as if you're begging for a like when you're doing so. I know how low self-esteem works, but unless you really make it part of the video, it seems unnecessary to say it.

summed up- great ideas but try working on talking enthusiastically.
 
Last edited:
Hey thanks. and I am still getting used to Youtubing. Those ragemart videos were all improv haha. And could you maybe review my newest video? Thoughts Ep.1

Also to the haven't subbed to me yet comment, if you are talking about my intro video, I said that because it's the unsubbed trailer.
 
Last edited:
Hey thanks. and I am still getting used to Youtubing. Those ragemart videos were all improv haha. And could you maybe review my newest video? Thoughts Ep.1

Also to the haven't subbed to me yet comment, if you are talking about my intro video, I said that because it's the unsubbed trailer.

Sorry there's been a lot of people asking reviews all of a sudden, i'll see whether i can review it later but i'm not promising anything.

Also the subbed me yet comment just seemed to sound judging, as in, you haven't subbed yet? wthell?/ but that's just my interpretation don't worry about that cx[DOUBLEPOST=1390925452,1390924765][/DOUBLEPOST]
Hey buddy! If you have the time, I'd like you to review my channel :) Let me know what's good about it, and what things I need to improve!

+
on video:
funny introduction, nice way of using clips and sound effects
very nice way of editing in text, together with the music
neat outro
-
on video:
at the point you actually start talking you're nearly whispering, a bit odd actually.
the video doesn't actually have much of you talking, i expected you to make a comment or whatever afterwards.

basically: not much you in the video really, so it's difficult to judge what your videos are like and how you vlog.
 
Alright ill try c: as you didnt put in a video tho, ill only review your channel trailer.
actually cuz that wasnt that much.. lemme review ragemart thing too
+
clear
says pretty much everything you do i suppose
ragemart vid:
your voice is good, clear and understandable
the talking in the game is pretty good
-
'you haven't subscribed to me yet' - I don't know why, but this makes me reluctant to sub, as it basically means you expect me to in the future (good if you're really confident, but can also seem a bit overconfi)
ragemart vid:
the intro is understandable, but the first jokes come after 40 seconds - try using a joke in the beginning or something to pull viewers in
the video is pretty long, maybe too long.
Background music would've been nice

- You have comedic talent, but theres quite some improv points.



Alright lets see, as you guys suggested i'll only review the video
+
the introduction is adorable, very much fun to hear.
all of your voices are clearly heard, good to follow
the entire lets-play is full of laughter and such, very entertaining
your accents are fascinating
-
co-operative videos with 3 people can become a bit difficult as it gets hard to know who is talking (for new viewers)
as you've said, its not very focused at the audience, but i personally have trouble doing that in co-ops so i'm not very sure how to help there :/
after you beat the level you repeated a part? with music? Maybe it's something you guys do as a sort of unique thing, but i don't really understand what it's for
The actual outro was 7 seconds or so, which is a bit short for me as a viewer to decide which of the four choices you gave i should click.
^ adding to the last two, your outro doesn't say much about you, it's good that there is an outro of sorts, but i believe if you would've just pot a clip of you guys saying 'bye guys, till next time' or anything like that, it'd have been a more logical ending.

Heh. looking at what i wrote it seems as if i found it bad because of the big amount of -'s, but seriously, you guys are really entertaining and seem like cool people to hang out with. Your video seems professional, but maybe your outro is a bit too vague.
anyway, was a pleasure to review you guys c:



sorry i posted this reply before reviewing you, misclick there. lets do that

+
channel trailer:
very good explanation of your channel in a comedic way, i like it
awesome use of background music
funny ending c:
video:
good hook into the video by giving such a tweet before the intro
'it was just like a skeleton in the class, and nobody knew' <- thats an amazing quote cx
your idea of reading tweets and criticizing them is definitely good, funny to see and watch you make fun of them tbh.
awesome outro
-
channel trailer:
You talk a bit slow, can be a good thing, but in this case i (personally) would prefer you talking a bit quicker and maybe more energetic. (i know thats not always possible, but i'd think it would improve as far as thats possible)
video:
again, you talk a bit slow, maybe take a bit too slow pauses which make it very easy to follow but a bit less entertaining. i know it's difficult to change but it is a consistent thing throughout the video, so it could definitely be beneficial for the entertainment value of the video.
You seem to have a lack of expression in the video, a possible tip is to attempt hyping yourself up, idk what you can get hyped about but it might work.
Well.. you seemed like you were about to cry at the end of the video. Might've just been me, and i don't mean anything bad by saying it, but i dont think it's good to get actually emotional in the video, unless it's your goal to do so (when screaming 'leave Britney alone' its alright to be emotional). <- and about the low self-esteem thing, i know how you feel, but it seems a bit... as if you're begging for a like when you're doing so. I know how low self-esteem works, but unless you really make it part of the video, it seems unnecessary to say it.

summed up- great ideas but try working on talking enthusiastically.

Thanks for the review, I really appreciated it! I think I know why it seem like i'm talking slow, I kinda just turn the camera on and react, The fake emotion clearly came off as weird and awkward and real which was not intended I'll definitely work on that in the future. Thanks again for all the feedback!
 
Here's my channel :D
Thanks a lot man :)

Hey there, looks like your channel trailer isnt much of a channel trailer cx so i'll just review on the sent video

+
good voice
clearly understandable, friend also understandable (lill less but good enough)
Your friend seems to be having fun c:
you really get into your role
nice outro c:
high quality video
-
No introduction, as a viewer who's only seen this video, i have no clue what you're supposed to do. (ok, i know what payday is and i know what minecraft is, but an introduction would still help out a lot)
You don't seem to enjoy playing it, its as if you're too concentrated on playing the game right that you forget to have fun doing so.
^Maybe you were having fun, but it didn't really seem like it, maybe try to be a bit less serious or something. Unless it's your goal to play get like the best score ever in the game, but that doesn't seem to be your focus. Also your voice being a bit monotone during the course of the video doesn't help there.

Oh god i look very negative here, what i mean to say is put some more expression into it, try to have some more fun and show it. oh and an introduction would be cool c:
On the other hand your setup seems to be good, audio and video are well done.

My channel is
I'd also like you to review my latest video:
Thanks!
~TheRoboDC

+
Intro is clear, understandable what's going on
you seem to have put a hella time into making that server, awesome c:
both your voices are reasonably understandable
You guys explain everything well
video is very good HQ (any chance you can tell me your recording program, editing program and output file format? :3)
good outro, also 'go to next vid' screen is pretty good.
-
klinja (or something) seems very nervous.
the difference in audio between you two scared me, like, i seriously got startled when you started talking as your audio is much louder. it's easy to fix, but its something you really need to be able to do
at 1:49 klinja's audio suddenly gets louder
it would've been a lot lot better if this was made into a montage, it takes longer to make it, but it'll look so much better and after putting such time into your server it seems fair to give the video some extra attention as well.

So i guess it's an alright video, but if you really want to showcase your map well you could make a montage or so.



that's very nice of you!
Can you review my channel? :3

Ill get to you guys tomorrow!
 
Back
Top