Allow me to gaze upon your channel...

Status
Not open for further replies.
The idea is that our channel is there as a hub for many different content creators and we give them freedom to create their shows/ideas how they want.
You could add something like "The creator hub for everybody" to the banner though ;)

Think of it like a poor-mans Maker, Machinima, Geek & Sundry or any other major 'Multichannel Network' (MCN). While we earn no ad revenue nor take sponsorships (and never will; we have ideas on how we can earn money but that's still a few years away), what we can provide and offer for the moment are our services.
I like the concept. It reminds me of Network A.

People should come to our channel for the shows and creators themselves - for 'Experience', for 'iNTERACT' etc. It was designed as a hub to showcase talented and creative individuals; a seal of quality if you will.
Include that in your channel trailer :)

I'm not knocking your suggestion of 'exciting video titles.' Your advice on that is absolutely rock solid, however, I don't want the 'Mind of Klink' to be just like every other channel/network. Allow me to use a gaming analogy here. You don't beat World of Warcraft by making 'World of Warcraft' (Age of Conan, Wildstar etc). You don't make a Call of Duty or Halo killer by making your game exactly like Call of Duty or Halo. You don't beat trends by following the trends. You beat trends by showing people there's a better alternative and that's exactly what we're aiming to do with our channel/network.
Sorry if I came around as if I was suggesting clickbait. What I meant is that you could do a better job in showing people what to expect from your videos. Currently you are hiding almost every content information from people and probably more important also from YouTube's algorithm. While it's very understandable that you don't want just to follow the crowd there are still techniques that have proven to simply work. Probably show one or the other of your thumbnails/titles to random people and ask them what video content they would expect. I guess very few people would click to watch a random interview but if the thumbnail (and the title) explain that it's about a comic book artist you may get many more interested.
I respect your attitude but my feeling is that you are missing out big opportunities without much reason.

Sorry for the massive wall of text.
Never mind.
 
Greetings everyone! Although I am new to YTTalk I'll be more than happy to check out any of your channels and offer my advice and honest critiques about them. A fresh pair of eyes just might be what your channel needs.

There are no stirct guidelines. Your channel can be about anything, target any demographic and be of any size. I'll offer my constructive criticisms regarding content, branding, art or technical issues.

Shall we begin?

Hey Man,
Me and my Friend own the channel and we have been struggling for a long time to gain views and subs.
So your advice would be a great enlightment on what went wrong.

Regards
Ray

PS: Saw your channel. It seems amazing... I am amazed how you are just stuck on 120 subs.
 
@ScienceIsFun

Of course it's still going. Chances are it will probably never end. What's the thread limit anyway?

The two main points you need to work on are your thumbnails and your audio. For thumbnails, there's no real way to distinguish that the content belongs to your channel. Adding in that 'W' from your logo/channel header in one of the corners will suffice. For audio, if you haven't already, consider investing in either a shotgun microphone for your camera or a wireless lavalier/lapel microphone. Currently your vocals are quite hollow with a bit of room noise/echo coming through, which suggests to me you're using the on-camera microphone. A shotgun or lavalier/lapel microphone will give you clearer, cleaner audio and knock out the room noise better than your curent setup.

Everything else you've got is phenomenal. Your branding is solid and your content is exceptional. I can see why you've gained so many subscribers and views in just 2 months. Work on the audio, give some consistency to your thumbnails and keep on making content. You're doing a fine job as it is so keep it up!

Thank you so much - I really appreciate this. :)
Completely agree on the thumbnails - I'm trying to put together a consistent theme/template for them, so I imagine the W or some form of sidebar will make an appearance at some point to make them consisten.
Appreciate the audio comments - I've experimented with a lapel (which stopped working so had to revert to my external recorder - which isn't on camera but people seem to complain about a lot). Have watched a few tutorials on audio processing, so hopefully future videos will be much more satisfactory in this department. And thanks for the positive feedback too! :D
 
Hey there!! A review of my channel would be great!! I haven't had any luck getting it reviewed yet. I would really appreciate it!
 
Wow @Klink, you're still here, lending advice and reviewing channels? You're a beast dude, much respect. Doing a good thing and helping a bunch of people.
 
@Ogi

Channel header and avatar are well designed but you should consider implementing those elements/designs into your thumbnails for that added consistency. Your thumbnails are consistent but like many other channels I've looked at in this thread, there's no clear indication that the videos belong to you. Having your pentagon logo in a corner will help.

Per your suggestion I'll only look at your latest two videos. In your intro skits you should really consider getting a tripod for your phone/camera or a small stabilising rig/selfie stick. Since you're holding it in your hand and trying to do moving shots (panning and/or dolly shot), your footage ends up incredibly unstable and shaky. THe further your hand is away from the body of a camera/your phone, the more stable your shot will look.

Your vocal audio is quite clear although I'm hearing a lot of popping. Keep your microphone further away from your mouth or save up money and invest in a pop filter.

Not really much more I can add. The more videos you create in this style, the better and more confident you'll become. Eventually, you'll stumble over your words less and be much more coherent and straight forward with your points without rambling. Keep it up! Best of luck to you!


@RetroRay

So far there's a lot of inconsistency with your channel. Your channel header, avatar and thumbnails are all completely different in design. Thumbnails are your biggest concern as they are quite generic and are absolutely no different to the millions of other videos on YouTube. What you have in your channel header is solid, so use that as a core design element of your brand and expand it to all your assets. Use that logo in your avatar and for your thumbnails, consider placing your logo in one of the corners, perhaps even creating a dark background triangle/diamond to create a consistent design element. From that point you can design your thumbnails however you want.

The same applies to your logo sting. It's currently based off the design in your avatar which is completely different to every other part of your brand. If you do enjoy that logo, start using that for your channel header and thumbnails instead of my previous suggestion. The key is to keep your branding consistent.

Content wise what you really need to work on is your audio. It's of significantly low quality which tells me you're using a cheap headset microphone. If you can (depending on your budget) consider investing in a high quality condenser microphone and pop-filter. You should also make sure not to peak your audio as it causes distortion which is distracting.

You've definitely improved a lot over the year you've been uploading content. Work on your audio, solidify your branding and don't give up making videos. Good luck!


@J krew flowless

Right off the bat your branding looks plain. Yes, you've kept the font/typeface and colours (mostly) consistent which is great! However, it doesn't change the fact that it looks generic and lazy. The colours you've selected are fine but what you need most is a simple logo that you can incorporate across all of your assets. Check out https://logopond.com to get some inspiration for designs. You could even make a simple text logo with the letters 'JKF' as a start.

Content wise you audio is really bad. Again, I can tell you're using a low quality headset microphone which is terrible for voice over work. At the moment you're hard to hear. If you can, save up some money and invest in a high quality condenser microphone and pop filter to increase the quality of your vocal work.

You also need to work on your audio mixing. Your vocals are quite soft compared to the music in your 'call to action/end card' which is exceptionally loud. Balance your audio so that the music doesn't over-power your vocals.

Work on your audio, clean up your branding and you're good to go. Good luck and have fun!


@Fee007

The biggest issue for your content right now is with your audio, more specifically with your microphone. It's significantly low quality and prone to peaking. Considering most of your vocal work can be done in post (after your recording), investing in a condenser microphone and pop-filter is a must. It'll give your vocals more clarity and help knock out some of the background noise present with some of your videos.

One more point on your audio - try to make sure that the music you've used doesn't over-power your vocals. It's not that big of an issue with your recent videos but in your earlier ones, your music was exceptionally louder compared to your vocals.

Another issue is with the clip-art images you've edited into your videos. They look incredibly cheap so I would recommend not using them for future videos.

Branding wise you've got some nice consistency with your thumbnails but not so much with your channel header and avatar. Your thumbnails have one font/typeface but your channel header uses 2 completely different ones that are both different in style. A key to good branding is consistency, so try to keep everything the same.

One final point, think about using the custom 'Home' page for your channel. It'll give you access to the 'Channel Trailer' section which will allow you to post your trailer video in there, giving your potential viewers a decent idea of what to expect from your channel. You can also use that space to promote your latest videos.

From what I can see, you're not doing too badly after 3 months of work. Your audio is holding you channel back, so work on that and your channel should grow. Best of luck to you!


@ehmaysi

Cheers man! By the way, your latest video is incredible! It seems you've really hit a trend with the 'Tilt Shift' technique, not to mention your music choice is excellent. I take it you just ask composers on SoundCloud for permission?

Keep it up man! It'll be a bit hard to continue your '52 videos in 52 weeks' considering the delay between this video and your last but as long as you continue your God-like editing skills you'll be fine.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top