Which thumbnail is much better?

[carlo1109]

I'm not a good at making thumbnails but I still tried to make one. I want to change my current thumbnail for that particular video but I don't know if I still need to change it. Please tell me which look better:
1st Thumbnail(New One)


or
2nd thumbnail (Current one used)


Thanks in advance!
Edit:
I edited the 1st thumbnail:

 

[Acidicfriend]

Second one totally.

 

[carlo1109]

Second one totally.

Thanks for the fast reply. Ok I'll still wait for other feedbacks

 

[Janzen]

The 2nd one is an eyecatcher

 

[Shane]

2nd one, solid colours are for the most part not good (red background)

 

[LuiC]

I'm not a good at making thumbnails but I still tried to make one. I want to change my current thumbnail for that particular video but I don't know if I still need to change it. Please tell me which look better:
1st Thumbnail(New One)
View attachment 22719
View attachment 22719
or
2nd thumbnail (Current one used)
View attachment 22720
View attachment 22720
Thanks in advance!

First one.

If you add a little more text or enlarge it, it should be fine.

 

[carlo1109]

First one.

If you add a little more text or enlarge it, it should be fine.

If I enlarge the text, the characters will be block by the text.

 

[LuiC]

If I enlarge the text, the characters will be block by the text.

You still have a LOT of blank spaces on the sides.
Use them.

 

[Zerodecoole]

2nd one! :U

 

[Switchbox]

Second one is much more appealing.