Which thumbnail is better?

[phoenixblue]

I made 2 thumbnails, can't decide which one to use.
They look completely different but which one do you guys think people would be more likely to click?

 

[Sinc]

the text looks so out of place, maybe make it feel like it belongs?

 

[RealFlame]

personally I prefer the second one since it is a bit brighter and the colours pop more

 

[KGATV]

Second. I like the colors, and the text outline. Though maybe make the text a bit bigger? Doesn't have to be much, but I feel when it's shrunk it's a bit harder to read.

 

[RealFlame]

yeah make the text a bit bigger. Also if you are doing this in ps add a drop shadow so the text stands out from the background

 

[NIP]

I prefer the 1st one because it has more action in the background. Thats just my opinion

 

[Camille Montpetit]

I prefer the first one I think the picture looks awesomeeeeee.
Plus I think the letters are just the right size. Since its a thumbnail, you need to have your letters really big.

 

[Bluebear]

second imo

 

[iLLwORkYOU]

Id got with the 2nd one but I would just add a little stroke to it maybe a 1 or 2 so that you can see it much clearer, and id fill the whole left side of the thumbnail up with the text. just me tho

 

[Rip the Script]

For me, the first one is my favorite. It's more intriguing, and stands out more, in my opinion