[QUOTE="Kaleido, post: 1775395, member: 36774]"I literally just watched a channel go from 20k to 200k in a couple of months. Plenty of people are finding an audience on Youtube without promotion...[/QUOTE]
I think 20k to 200k is much easier than 0k to 20k. How did that channel progress from 0 to 20k and how long did it take? Did they get help from other Youtubers at all? What genre are they? Some genres are much harder to break into than others. I was talking to my daughter the other day and asking her about various gamers and telling her to get tips from seeing how other successful Gaming channels started out. One by one I asked her about her favorite gamers. Stacy plays, dantdm, etc. It seemed like 90% of them got help or a head start from other prominent youtubers along the way. I'm not saying it's not possible to grow a gaming channel without help, but it seems like many of the top gaming channels today did get a leg up along the way. I'm sure there are some examples of gaming channels recently that have gone from starting from scratch to a couple hundred thousand subscribers over a relatively short period of time, but I haven't seen many examples of that.
As far as YouTube promoting big gamers, if they are so high on retention and long session length as indicators of quality content, then why would they be afraid to put their money where their mouth is and promote smaller channels whose average relative retention is high which would indicate quality content that people would want to see? I mean, I realize that promoting PewDiePie in that list of popular channels is a sure bet, but theoretically they could do just as well if not better by promoting smaller channels with high retention rates.