Hey guys... I emailed Amazon asking for clarification about my original rejection. Since I got the exact same email (a canned response) as the OP, here's what I asked clarification on:
I have a couple questions that I hope you can answer for me.
1. Is this effectively saying that I don't have enough susbcribers and/or videos and that I could re-apply in the future once my channel is larger?
2. Am I allowed to re-apply with a new account if I had my old one closed for the above reason?
Thanks, I hope you can provide some clarity.
I thought you guys would get a laugh at the canned-response reply.
"I've reviewed your application and can confirm it's been rejected. Once you have a stronger following, and you've updated your site to contain unique and original content, please reapply using Facebook.com "Fan Pages," a "Verified" Twitter.com page, a YouTube "channel" page, or a Twitch.tv page and we'll be happy to review it. Here's the URL for submitting a new application:
[normal join link here]
We hope to see you again soon."
Ultimately they just re-iterated the original rejection e-mail, worded in a different way. At least they effectively confirmed that I "can" re-apply. I'm still firmly convinced that the reason I was rejected was because of the size of my channel. I'm pretty convinced the same applies to the OP, which is why I mentioned it. I guess time will tell
Want more evidence? Read the following article and search for the text "500 subscribers".
https://blog.geni.us/2014/10/15/using-affiliate-links-in-youtube-best-practices/
Google: "blog.geni.us" 500 subscribers
The article is titled "USING AFFILIATE LINKS IN YOUTUBE: BEST PRACTICES".
geni.us is a company that provides a link shortening service that has worked with Amazon to ensure they follow the guidelines. Linus Tech Tips uses them so that's how I know of them.
It's not concrete proof, but hey they spoke with someone at Amazon and were told 500+ subs. This article is where I got the 500 subs # from I mentioned originally. This is why I'm re-applying when I hit 500 subs.
I don't know under what circumstances that Roberto Blake had his associates account terminated, but it must be for a unique reason as he was clearly big enough to be bringing in large amounts of commissions.