The secret behind top comments

[MegaBoringGuy]

Not true. You of all people should know this, having your "brother" spam every video talking about you hurting him for not liking your channel or something.

Turn off your burner, dude. Those comments are a pain in the a**, since my main channel's comments have been getting ghosted. If this is "not true", what is the case for yourself? It's not thumbs up on the comment or replies.

 

[TrueBijoux]

Turn off your burner, dude. Those comments are a pain in the a**, since my main channel's comments have been getting ghosted. If this is "not true", what is the case for yourself? It's not thumbs up on the comment or replies.

If it gets ghosted, change it. You will be able to use that comment in 24 hours. That is, if it doesn't show up in the "Newest Comments" section. If your comments aren't showing up in top comments, that's a whole other reason

 

[dillonsup]

Google+ Why You Do This? The Commenting System Now Sucks. Even If Bob Was to build an army to Stop Google. They Would Be able to Blow The army away D: R.I.P Bob

 

[MegaBoringGuy]

If it gets ghosted, change it. You will be able to use that comment in 24 hours. That is, if it doesn't show up in the "Newest Comments" section. If your comments aren't showing up in top comments, that's a whole other reason

Thanks for the suggestion (I was expecting to get sworn at *hue hue). My comments have been getting ghosted for weeks - editing doesn't do anything, waiting doesn't help, so I made comments with the other account and replied to it, but that broke, so all I can do is +reply myself. Looking at how it was for me in the beginning, yourself and others, it's a killer way to get subs. I saw you got 3000 or so in the past month, bloody impressive.

 

[TrueBijoux]

Thanks for the suggestion (I was expecting to get sworn at *hue hue). My comments have been getting ghosted for weeks - editing doesn't do anything, waiting doesn't help, so I made comments with the other account and replied to it, but that broke, so all I can do is +reply myself. Looking at how it was for me in the beginning, yourself and others, it's a killer way to get subs. I saw you got 3000 or so in the past month, bloody impressive.

haha no problem! once again though, by ghosted do you mean it doesn't show up in the top comments section, or the newest comments section? If it's not showing up in newest there's a few things you can do:

-Like I've said edit it. Trust me, there's probably one key word that you are using that is just making every comment of yours go to the spam section of their comments. Once I figured this out I started posting comments without it, and it worked. 24 hours later the same comment that wouldn't work now was perfectly fine

-Change your IP. I don't know why but whenever nothing worked I would unplug and replug my modem and everything would be fine.

-Wait a bit. I don't know how many times I've thought it didn't work and then 5 minutes later check again and it appears.

Now, if your comments aren't showing up in top comments but ARE showing up in newest ... well I'm pretty sure it's obvious why that's happening

 

[MegaBoringGuy]

haha no problem! once again though, by ghosted do you mean it doesn't show up in the top comments section, or the newest comments section? If it's not showing up in newest there's a few things you can do:

-Like I've said edit it. Trust me, there's probably one key word that you are using that is just making every comment of yours go to the spam section of their comments. Once I figured this out I started posting comments without it, and it worked. 24 hours later the same comment that wouldn't work now was perfectly fine

-Change your IP. I don't know why but whenever nothing worked I would unplug and replug my modem and everything would be fine.

-Wait a bit. I don't know how many times I've thought it didn't work and then 5 minutes later check again and it appears.

Now, if your comments aren't showing up in top comments but ARE showing up in newest ... well I'm pretty sure it's obvious why that's happening

Ghosted meaning it won't show up in top comments, new comments, or in reply to my other channel's comment that does show up - so not at all. Thanks a lot for all the ideas, I shall test all of this in a little while.

 

[MashedUpCod]

It looks like the most recent comment appears on the "Top Comment" page for a while. The top comment is determined on how much interaction the comment gets, mainly replies.

 

[MAZONAKUS]

I wish every comment I made was a top comment...

 

[MegaBoringGuy]

@TrueBijoux Editing the comment for spam words did help the comments be seen, thank you, though how to get them as a top comment eludes me still. Any advice on that?

 

[TrueBijoux]

Ghosted meaning it won't show up in top comments, new comments, or in reply to my other channel's comment that does show up - so not at all. Thanks a lot for all the ideas, I shall test all of this in a little while.

the proper term for that would be banned. The user who's video you commented on has banned you from their channel. This means you can't comment on their videos, reply to any comments on their videos, or leave a comment on their channel. due to the fact that you are probably commenting on popular channels, there is no hope of getting unbanned. Just never comment on their videos again because it will never show up. The way you can tell is by replying to someone's comment on that video. Replies are different than actual comments: there is no limit and it will not be ghosted no matter what they say. Therefore, if it doesn't show up then you are banned. However you will still see the comment on the account you posted it with, but any other account will not.

It looks like the most recent comment appears on the "Top Comment" page for a while. The top comment is determined on how much interaction the comment gets, mainly replies.

Incorrect. I could comment potato, disable replies and have no thumbs up and stay top comment for hours.