Struggling with Black Borders

Locarno1

Member
Hi All,

I'm very interested in starting to make flying videos for Youtube and other broadcasting sites, and after seeing a few videos on YouTube for this hobby, I'd love to get involved and have wanted to do this for ages. I have OBS but currently having some issue with it when using a certain add-on aircraft which I'm investigating, but also have Nvidia Shadowplay.

I'm using Sony Vegas to edit my videos, but they seem to, when uploaded to YouTube come out with black borders? But in the preview inside Sony Vegas, there are no black borders. I've set the aspect ratio correct and the rendered settings as 1920x1080.

I was just wondering if anyone has made videos before and made them good quality for YouTube at all? I have uploaded a very quick video to see how it comes out, and here you can see what I mean about the black borders..

My home monitor is 1920x1200, not sure if that affects anything?

(Wanted to link to my video which shows the issues I'm having but it didn't allow me..)

Hope I can get some help and advice if possible. I'm really sorry if this is a noob question, but I really want to start somewhere and we all have to start somewhere.

Regards,

Tristan
 
make sure you set not only the render to 1920x1080, but the actual project, so you can crop or stretch stuff there (Vegas might render the video in a way that tells yt to stretch from 16:9 to 16:10). Also when uploading 16:10 content, YT likes to put black bars into the actual transcoded video, so it becomes 16:9
 
make sure you set not only the render to 1920x1080, but the actual project, so you can crop or stretch stuff there (Vegas might render the video in a way that tells yt to stretch from 16:9 to 16:10). Also when uploading 16:10 content, YT likes to put black bars into the actual transcoded video, so it becomes 16:9

Hi Cvolton,

Really appreciate the help, thank you! I've had a look at the project settings and you were right I think, because my monitor is bigger than 1080, I think that is why it was producing a border. I've uploaded a test video to youtube and when in fullscreen it works. However, when not in fullscreen on youtube, there are black borders either side, any idea why this could be?
 
Hi Cvolton,

Really appreciate the help, thank you! I've had a look at the project settings and you were right I think, because my monitor is bigger than 1080, I think that is why it was producing a border. I've uploaded a test video to youtube and when in fullscreen it works. However, when not in fullscreen on youtube, there are black borders either side, any idea why this could be?
as I've said, when you upload a 16:10 video to YouTube, YT adds black borders on the side to make it 16:9, however due to your monitor being 16:10, you also get the black borders on the top and bottom of the video, since it has to fit the space somehow to make it 16:10 again
 
as I've said, when you upload a 16:10 video to YouTube, YT adds black borders on the side to make it 16:9, however due to your monitor being 16:10, you also get the black borders on the top and bottom of the video, since it has to fit the space somehow to make it 16:10 again

Is there anyway I can change this? I've changed the project size to 1920x1200 now.. And it fills up my monitor on Youtube. Just find it weird with other people's videos, they fill up my screen and show great quality in both full screen and non-full screen.

I'm a little confused what I'm doing to be honest..
 
Is there anyway I can change this? I've changed the project size to 1920x1200 now.. And it fills up my monitor on Youtube. Just find it weird with other people's videos, they fill up my screen and show great quality in both full screen and non-full screen.

I'm a little confused what I'm doing to be honest..
when you're uploading a 1200p video to YouTube, YT downscales it to 1080p, resulting in a slight quality decrease. Maybe you can try rendering in 1440p (would be 2304x1440 for 16:10) or 2160p (4k, would be 3456x2160). Also another cause of quality decrease is YT transcoding the video into a lower bitrate, so it's more online streaming friendly. People getting more views on a regular basis get their videos transcoded into VP9, which has higher quality. Again 1440p/2160p both have higher bitrates, so playing at these qualities will give you some quality improvement, even if the original is 1080p (or 1200p in your case)
 
Back
Top