Hi, we recently purchased an Elgato for our Xbox 360 recording, it's a little more expensive than you said you wanted to get, but it really is the best one out there it seems. Particularly the software is what sets its apart from the others, as you can go back in time in case you missed something, and also livestream directly to Twitch from there. We have recorded FIFA and GTA on our channel using the Elgato, and it has produced really high quality videos!