Quote from Weird Al:You actually have to get permission from the owner of the song (record label) to record your own version be it a parody or your version of the performance. That is not just me blurting out words, that is actual fact. Weird Al pays for the songs he uses up to a certain point. It´s just as with a cover, it is copyright infringement to use another persons song in a video or recording without getting permission for it. That means the melody and song structure as well not just the lyrics! People get away with doing parodies because the original owner of the song either likes the parody and/or it makes people interested in their original version of the song which they then look for and possibly buy.
Jonathan
Since that statement was made Copyright law has changed or he is not fully aware of the law. The law supports critique and ridicule yes, but not full on change without owner permission or else I could cover any song I wanted and just change some lyrics around and say it´s a parody (which with my current singing ability would not be far from the truth lol)Quote from Weird Al:
" Yes, I do get permission from the original songwriters. While the law supports my ability to parody without permission, it's very important to me to try to maintain the relationships I've built with artists and writers over the years. Thankfully, most artists seem genuinely flattered to get the "Weird Al treatment." Some groups (including Nirvana) have publicly stated that they didn't realize that they had really "made it" until they heard my parody! "
They could sue him for that and according to the legal President we have now they would win the case. Also I doubt respect had anything to do with his decision about not putting the songs on his record. You need permission from the song owner to overall record the song legally and you need a legal contract to earn money from using that song even though it has changed lyrics, it´s still the song structure and melody...Weird Al has actually been denied permission from James Blunt and Lady Gaga to parody their song so instead of releasing the song on his record(Out of respect) he releases them free of charge on his website because he doesn't need their permission.