Ok what you said makes perfect sense. So my next question would be how do you get your video on suggested videos or browse features.
When my dayz fails video did so well I made a dayz fails #2, used all the same tags and everything. Only received 100 views more than half were my subscribers..
It doesn't really make any sense.
Okay so when you first make a video, YouTube will use your metadata (title/tags/description/closed captioning) to give it some free ranking for a few days. During that time, YouTube "tests" out your video. It looks at all the clicks you get from search etc, and sees how well those clicks fared. Did people click and then leave after 2 seconds? Or did people stay and watch most/all of the video.
If people watched a decent amount of your video that suggests they enjoyed it - so, your video stays ranked in search after the initial free ranking period is over.
If they watched an okay amount but not super great, then it'll stay ranked but it'll drop down to a lower ranking than it was initially given.
If on the other hand most people watched most of the video, then the ranking will even increase if more people seem to like your video than other related videos.
If you search for "dayz standalone fails", your first video is the 4th video to pop up on the first page. Your second video shows up in search too.. but all the way back on page 4, where barely anyone is likely to see it.
I can think of two potential reasons why this may have happened:
Possible reason 1: It simply got lower audience retention times. If overall people watched less of the video, then YouTube sees that as evidence that it was less engaging, and so it ranks poorly.
Possible reason 2: Since the title is the main thing that determines your ranking on the first day before YouTube has any data to improve your rankings, because of the #2 in the title it might not have shown up on page 1 right away. It might have been on page 4 to begin with. If then your audience retention times didn't meet a certain threshold, it kept its ranking but didn't improve.
I believe the way search ranking works is your audience retention is most important, but after that views are also important. A video with 100,000 views but only 5% audience retention will rank really low, while a video with 1000 views and 90% audience retention will rank really high.. but if 2 videos both have say ~50% audience retention, and one of them has 20,000 views while the other has 10,000 views, the one with more views will rank higher.
This means it's slightly harder for you to get a good ranking if you don't get enough views during the first few days. So if your video starts out on page 4, it might never really rank unless you get enough views from elsewhere.
My personal rule of thumb when making videos that I want to be searchable is I try to make them so they rank in page 1 for at least some search term. Even if it's not the main one I want to rank for.. I want to be getting in enough views those first few days so that I keep/improve my rankings.
You can find out which of those reasons caused it btw by looking in analytics, and typing in the video name for one of the videos, then going into the "Audience Retention" tab. Make a note of the "Average percentage viewed" part for that video. Now type in the same of the other video and do the same thing. If the % is quite a bit higher for video 1, then that's your rankings explained right there.
In general longer videos even if they're just as good will have slightly lower % retention times, simply because people sometimes get bored and click off earlier etc.
Also as for ranking in suggested videos/browse features. I believe if your video has been doing relatively well and getting enough views with good audience retention, then YouTube will automatically "test out" your video on their home page or in suggested videos. Again this is just a few days, where they gather information about whether it did well. If it seemed to do well, your video will stay recommended to people there. If not, it'll go back to not being recommended.