Allow me to gaze upon your channel...

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hey I know this is a little late, but I would really appreciate if you could look over my channel. I am in the process of buying a new camera to fix the overall quality but I would love to hear opinions on other things I could fix in order to build a better Youtube channel.
 
i would appreciate any feed back onmy channel honestly i wanna improve so to do so i need to know about the opinion of others
 
@mreasthito

You've got an interesting concept. While using text-to-speech is nothing new, you're writing a script that features 3 characters/voices on top of timing it to your video edits. Furthermore you've gone through and added both English and Chinese subtitles. Honestly, I admire your dedication and respect the amount of work you've put into this one video. Well done!

What I would suggest is that you start creating your own characters for future videos. Touhou characters are great but they don't belong to you. While I'm aware that there's a lot of fanart and fan work featuring Touhou characters, making your own will ensure that your channel is truly unique.

I'd like to see more videos from you. You have skill, you have talent and you have dedication; all the ingredients to succeed on YouTube.


@Jake Fuller

I'm looking at both your channels and I can tell that your 'Daily Vlog' channel is what you're focusing on and more passionate about. Your 'JAKEL33T' channel definitely has a more consistent branding compared to your Vlog channel but the quality of the vlogs is significantly worse in video quality. It's great to see good green screen work on that channel but it falls apart when it's just you in (mostly) complete silence with the game audio turned down too low (especially with the Portal playthrough). I'm well aware that the content is just you re-uploading streams but whether it's livestreaming or well edited and produced videos on YouTube, you need to be engaging with your fans to keep their interest. Obviously you don't need to go overboard (PewDiePie, Markiplier etc) but you do need to be more engaging.

From this point on I'll be focusing on your 'Daily Vlogs' channel. The channel header and thumbnails from 'Haircut | Computer Setup' to 'Hump Day' are spot on. The black and white colour scheme with red for highlights is very noir in style and looks good. Your avatar sticks out like a sore thumb by contrast so think about keeping it in line with the design of your channel header.

For the recent gameplay video (Diablo 3 Reaper of Souls [Season 6]) I'm noticing a lot of plosives in your audio. This was also an issue with your other channel as well. You've got a decent microphone setup with a pop filter but I think what's happening is that you've got your mic gain turned up way too high to compensate for your soft speaking voice. It's making your breath and plosive consonants pop in your audio which doesn't sound professional at all. Try aiming the microphone slightly above your mouth or move the mic further away.

Your vlogs are fine and are higher quality compared to those on your other channel. Nothing really more to add on this point.

Keep at it. It's hard getting noticed and popular on YouTube so be dedicated, be persistent and you'll eventually find success. Good luck!


@Welcome2Internet

The editing in your videos is excellent; nothing more I can add. I would suggest a pop filter for your microphone to give your audio a more professional edge but your audio quality suits your videos perfectly. It's also nice to see a consistent brand across all of your art assets.

It's a great start and you're doing quite well for 3 weeks worth of work. Keep at it! I know your channel will be successful. Best of luck to you!


@jakemealer

It's never to late, my friend. I'll avoid talking about camera quality and concentrate on the other aspects of your channel and content.

The biggest issue for your content at the moment is the audio mixing. It definitely got better with your third video but in your first two, the music you added in is extremely loud compared to your commentary. It's important to keep in mind for future videos to ensure a level volume throughout.

Depending on how far you want to take your content, you might want to consider investing in a shotgun microphone for your new camera. It'll help clean up your audio but it may be awkward to carry around since you're doing everything handheld. You should also think about investing in a tripod for those moments where you can sit down and plan about what you're going to talk about instead of doing everything on the fly.

Branding wise it's good that you've got photos of yourself for your avatar and thumbnails. You're a vlogs channel so it's all about you. Consider choosing a font/typeface that you think looks good and represents you and use that for your channel header and text within your thumbnails. Screenshots from the video are servicable but not very professional.

Finally, use the custom 'Home' page layout instead of the default so you can use the 'Channel Trailer' space to promote your latest videos. It's a good way to let potential viewers to your channel know what your content is all about.

It's a good start for your channel. Once you get that new camera of yours, keep making content and keep a regular upload schedule. The more you do it, the better you'll get and the more viewers and subscribers you'll earn. Best of luck!


@Koa

I love your logo and I love how you've incorporated it into your thumbnails. With the exception of your channel header which could use work, you've got a nice consistent branding right out of the gate. Good work! All you really need for your channel header is your logo. If you want to add images, treat it in the same way as you've done in your thumbnails - blur them to draw a viewers eye to the logo itself rather than the image.

On the topic of branding, you don't need to have you logo in the top right hand corner in that size. There's an option in your channel settings which should allow you to upload a little custom brand logo that appears either at the beginning, end or throughout the entirely of your video. It's less distracting that way and serves a practical purpose since it can be used as a link to subscribe to your channel.

Definitely use the custom 'Home' page for your channel so you can use the 'Channel Trailer' space to promote your latest videos and allow potential viewers to see what your channel is all about.

In terms of content, audio quality seems to be the biggest issue. It sounds like you're using a headset microphone which is causing a lack of quality in your vocals. If you don't already have one, invest in a high quality condenser microphone and make sure to save the audio as .WAV files. When you upload to YouTube, it processes the videos and compress it on top of your own rendering/compression.

Not bad for 2 weeks worth of work. You've definitely got potential. Just keep uploading videos regularly and work on the issues I've mentioned. Good luck!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Koa
@Klink

That is exactly what it was, I got that video into post and the volume was low so I upped the gain, I still had the mic set for my streaming setup. I had to speak quietly due to a sleeping baby for that video. Thanks for the advice. Ep.2 will be better because of it.

Also I am not uploading to JAKEL33T at all anymore, I think I should remove it from my signature/featured channel.

As far as my channel icon, I agree it needs to mesh better. I'll get that done tonight.
 
Thank you man i highly appreciate it and yea im still learning so things you said are deff things i will be looking to improve or fix. the mic i have a snow ball but im still trying to know what volume and what type of setting to use for alot of my editing im still on learning proccess but i appreciate it
 
@Gods of Odds

Right off the bat your channel header and avatar are perfect; simple, clean and fits the theme/name of your channel. Try to incorporate those elements into your thumbnails since currently they're poorly designed in contrast. Most of the text you've got in your thumbnails is unreadable, you've only got screenshots or promotional art which is generic and there's nothing in them to imply that the videos belong to your channel at all. Choose a corner to place a blue triangle/diamond with your logo in them and use the same font/typeface and text style (slight emboss, slight drop shadow) as the primary header text to ensure the text is clear and easy to read.

Biggest issue for your channel is your audio. I'm hearing a lot of echo and a lot of distortion which I'm assuming is due to your noise reduction process or your audio compression. It could also be due to you using a headset mic but I can't be too sure. If you haven't got one, invest in a condenser microphone and pop filter and when recording your audio, record at least 10 seconds of room noise to then use as a sample to capture the noise print and remove it. You don't need to play around with too many settings if you've got a clean sample so try it with the default settings and play around with it if needed.

Not bad for 2 months of work overall. Work on your branding, clean up your audio and you'll be good to go. Best of luck!
 
@Gods of Odds

Right off the bat your channel header and avatar are perfect; simple, clean and fits the theme/name of your channel. Try to incorporate those elements into your thumbnails since currently they're poorly designed in contrast. Most of the text you've got in your thumbnails is unreadable, you've only got screenshots or promotional art which is generic and there's nothing in them to imply that the videos belong to your channel at all. Choose a corner to place a blue triangle/diamond with your logo in them and use the same font/typeface and text style (slight emboss, slight drop shadow) as the primary header text to ensure the text is clear and easy to read.

Biggest issue for your channel is your audio. I'm hearing a lot of echo and a lot of distortion which I'm assuming is due to your noise reduction process or your audio compression. It could also be due to you using a headset mic but I can't be too sure. If you haven't got one, invest in a condenser microphone and pop filter and when recording your audio, record at least 10 seconds of room noise to then use as a sample to capture the noise print and remove it. You don't need to play around with too many settings if you've got a clean sample so try it with the default settings and play around with it if needed.

Not bad for 2 months of work overall. Work on your branding, clean up your audio and you'll be good to go. Best of luck!
Thanks for the review and yep I agree with all of that. The thumbnails we are currently changing, the audio echo I'm not completely sure how to get rid of it although I am trying, I use a Blue Snowball Ice. What does a pop filter actually do?
 
Hey!
So far I'm mostly vlogging and trying to be entertaining. The channel is new and has less than 20 subs. I'll add my latest video, but if you have time I would appreciate it so much if you could have a look at the channel itself.
It's such a good thing you're keeping up with this thread, I am sure you've helped lots of people. :)

 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top