I did sub4sub the first week and got about 20 subs before I said F that. It's a terrible way to go.
I have built several websites and as a result have learned a fair amount about SEO.
I have a dot com website with all my videos, a blog that's full of relevant tags and links to my channel, and my videos have pretty lengthy relevant descriptions.
That's all good for traffic, but to get people to click subscribe I basically just ask them at the end of every video in a non desperate way. I am also really active on YouTube.
I find smaller channels with the same content and I say something like, "nice video, I really like your commentary. I'm trying to get better."
Instead of asking them to sub to me. People like positive feedback and I feel like they visit my channel with a happy attitude, hopefully they see a video they like, and sub.
For me the importance is:
Above all. Quality content, attractive channel design. Then:
1.SEO (how can they sub if they can't find you?)
2. Find communities like YTtalk, YouTube, g+, FB etc... And be active daily.
3. Do whatever it takes to be confident in your channel so you can hand out business cards, tell your friends and family with confidence that your channel is badass.