Thumbnails Review - redesigned by professionals

[Steves World]

Need your advice. The attached image are three of my LOW performing thumbnails - under 2%

Each one has been redesigned by another person - I used different 4 designers.

If you have a minute can you post which thumbnail you might click on in each row.
Row A -
Row B -
Row C -



Thank you so much for any comments.
Steve's Real World

 

[BoxForAFox]

Okay, okay. So...

Row A - B
Row B - C
Row C - B
Row D - C


I feel like each of these are easier to read and have a more clickable design!

 

[Steves World]

Thank you BoxForAFox.

I hope to get more opinions.
More info: Each thumbnail by a designer cost $10 each.
But one designer sent me three for the New Puppy video.
About 1/2 the price of Custom Thumbnails website.

Thoughts please!!

 

[Kyonite]

I think all of column C are the best of their rows, except for row d, which the first one is better.

 

[UhoohExtra]

Row A - A

Row B - C

Row C - C

Row D - C

some thoughts .. the doggie ones look like gaming thumbnails which may be why they are getting lower CTR for non gaming content. With 'Teach your puppy to sit' video 2:52.8 is your killer thumbnail (before she blinks) - just add some white bold text against the dark wooden floor to the right. I guess remember the title text may affect CTR also so it may not be your thumbnail performing badly.. could be either or combination of etc.

 

[duchaiyb]

I find it quite attractive