Lilikoi Juice
I do all my own graphics!
I like it! I prefer the second one because it has more depth and warmth.
I'd suggest using the same background style (is that a circular gradient?) you have for your vlog banner. It should give it more depth and contrast to the image so it doesn't look so flat. It'll also extend more "image" to the left side, since it's empty and you have a lot going on toward the right side. Of course, if you already like how it looks then go with what you want because it looks good regardlessdata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7967d/7967db43e94d03f7a2f362513e808495d69661ab" alt="Smile :) :)"
EDIT: Oh! I saw the update. It looks ten times better!
I'd suggest using the same background style (is that a circular gradient?) you have for your vlog banner. It should give it more depth and contrast to the image so it doesn't look so flat. It'll also extend more "image" to the left side, since it's empty and you have a lot going on toward the right side. Of course, if you already like how it looks then go with what you want because it looks good regardless
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7967d/7967db43e94d03f7a2f362513e808495d69661ab" alt="Smile :) :)"
EDIT: Oh! I saw the update. It looks ten times better!