Vignette. Yes or no?

[Andrew Flint]

Really need help deciding this!
This is the film I'm making with a group of college mates for our project and I'm editing it.. really need help deciding if I should use a Vignette or no on the film (it's a zombie film)
Left is without colour correction and Vignette and right is with the Vignette and colour correct. So don't comment on the colour different just the effect the Vignette has please

 

[Unknown_User12]

Yes, but decrease it. It's too strong

 

[unknown_userr433436365]

Yes , but turn down the opacity abit and make it a dark wine colour instead

 

[TwinTails]

I think vignette gives it more of a movie feel ^_^

 

[Andrew Flint]

Yes, but decrease it. It's too strong

Yes , but turn down the opacity abit and make it a dark wine colour instead

I've feathered it out a bit more so the edges aren't pretty much black does look a lot better then before haha thanks for the advice! just I just have to wait for the effect to be applied to around 4000 frames.. and that's only 2 minutes of the film :L

 

[Unknown_User12]

I've feathered it out a bit more so the edges aren't pretty much black does look a lot better then before haha thanks for the advice! just I just have to wait for the effect to be applied to around 4000 frames.. and that's only 2 minutes of the film :L

4000 frames? Dafuq frame rate did you shoot/edit in?

 

[Chase Butler]

I'm going to say yes, but turn it down a little bit and see how it looks

 

[Chase Butler]

4000 frames? Dafuq frame rate did you shoot/edit in?

That's some where around 30fps because he said it was about 2min of film

 

[Favoring]

Vignettes looks best on 10 - 15% opacity.

 

[Unknown_User12]

That's some where around 30fps because he said it was about 2min of film

Oh s**t. I was in C4D mode, where a minute is 60 frames. Okay, yeah that makes more sense. Fail