Elgato Game Capture HD or Roxio Game Capture HD Pro?

[jaacobthompson]

I'm planning on buying one of the two so I can get better videos for my channel, I was just wandering if anybody knew which is the better of the two? Which records better quality videos, which is easier to set up and use, which comes with better editing software etc.

 

[SamaJaffa]

Elgato hands down. Done. Don't even think about anything else XD

 

[Z3 Mast3r]

Definitely elgato. But i think you should consider the HD PVR 2 Gaming Edition instead of the Roxio HD Pro.
These two videos might help.

 

[JosPlays]

I have Roxio Game Capture HD, it works with HDMI and was cheap.

 

[jaacobthompson]

Elgato it is, Thanks!

 

[aranyoli1231]

Elgato Game Capture HD is the best Recording Device out there! I have one and it's wonderful! I record Black Ops 2 Vids with it and it's awsome!