Too Many Similar Thumbnails?

[FleaIsStupid]

So usually, for thumbnails, I have a preset for each series, and I edit it slightly, whether it be changing the background image, or altering a number for the episode. I looked at my Channel this morning, kind of analyzing everything and found that I'm unsure if I have too many similar looking thumbnails. Keep in mind my Pokemon series is daily, and otherwise I post things every other day.
Are they too similar to each other, or am I just being a bit too critical? (There are also 2 videos in there that I'm currently working on Thumbnails for, so disregard them)

 

[Kath]

I just checked out your channel....and...I don't have a problem with how it's all the same background......but it might be better if you made the E01 stand out more. Maybe if you used a black font, or black stroke, it'd be easier for people to see . What could potentially end up happening is, people won't click on the other videos, because they'll think they've already seen it. On your mine craft videos, I would have the numbers just a little larger. I think you've done a great job with the thumbnails and they look cohesive nonetheless.

 

[FleaIsStupid]

I just checked out your channel....and...I don't have a problem with how it's all the same background......but it might be better if you made the E01 stand out more. Maybe if you used a black font, or black stroke, it'd be easier for people to see . What could potentially end up happening is, people won't click on the other videos, because they'll think they've already seen it. On your mine craft videos, I would have the numbers just a little larger. I think you've done a great job with the thumbnails and they look cohesive nonetheless.

Thank you kindly, I always have a problem with that :/ It looks so large when I'm editing the image, and then it ends up not standing out when it's squished down in size. I'll for sure keep it in mind!

 

[Symph]

I just checked out your channel....and...I don't have a problem with how it's all the same background......but it might be better if you made the E01 stand out more. Maybe if you used a black font, or black stroke, it'd be easier for people to see . What could potentially end up happening is, people won't click on the other videos, because they'll think they've already seen it. On your mine craft videos, I would have the numbers just a little larger. I think you've done a great job with the thumbnails and they look cohesive nonetheless.

anything this woman says about graphic design, LISTEN. She makes my thumbnails, and sometimes I just look at them for hours on end in amazement LOL[DOUBLEPOST=1367161284,1367161254][/DOUBLEPOST]hey speaking of which, I know you've got some "things" going on Kat, but you are slacking as my thumbnail girl COME ON.

 

[awepsie]

Yeah, bud! As long as the number of the episode stands out, I like it!

 

[jochem]

i dont have a problem with the same backgrounds (i do it myself )
but make sure you keep your thumbnails unique to those of others, for example, anyone on youtube playing alice in wonderland madness returns has a thumbnail of their real life self with a butchers knife. and it just starts looking casual and lazy and uncreative.
but your thumbnails are all fine when it comes to the background etc. just watch out you dont make the letters to small

 

[Kath]

anything this woman says about graphic design, LISTEN. She makes my thumbnails, and sometimes I just look at them for hours on end in amazement LOL[DOUBLEPOST=1367161284,1367161254][/DOUBLEPOST]hey speaking of which, I know you've got some "things" going on Kat, but you are slacking as my thumbnail girl COME ON.

I know I know! I forgot again...I'm going to a birthday party soon...definitely tonight. And thank you for your kind words!!!! I love doing your thumbnails!!