Rate our OneChannel background, banner and logo?

Magic_Soap

Magic_Soap

Active Member
Channel link is here link
We have yet to do a proper trailer, but everything else including links is set up.
What do you guys think? What would you change?
 
Maybe a more unique logo instead of just a standard "OP" with a font.
Banner looks good if you like the style, so I'd say about 7/10 :)
 
Yeah aim for something a little more personal that would define you more rather then something that would be put together in 20min. If you want to have a professional look about your banner try to think of what defines you more than the other gaming channel out there. I based mine around a mascot. Try to find your vibe. Also you should make a real specific video for your trailer and take something really short like less than 3min. New people wont want to spend 8min to decide if they'll want to follow you or not. So i suggest doing a mashup of your best moment or doing a video that presents your channel well. (You can look at mine for a kind of reference if you'd like) or you can go in a complete different direction, your call :p
 
Okay, its great for some constructive criticism, but really I did say that this isn't our official trailer, we haven't made one yet. I know you only took a quick glance, but still. Also the problem is we aren't a single person like your average s****y Call of Duty single commentator. And um, yeah it did take longer than 20 mins.
 
I didnt meant to insult you, it's a font with a background of smoke. I get you probably spend a lot of time on it if it's your first attempt but a professionnal would do this in about 20min. Beside you came here asking for improvement and criticism i believe. If you just wanted praises i think it's very shallow of you, but i dont think it's the case here. Your banner is good don't get me wrong but it doesnt stand out is what i'm trying to say. I do like the fact that its simple, but it doesnt represent your channel. You said it incorporate multiple persons in it... i didnt get that vibe when looking at it. Anyway best of luck and sorry if i offended you it wasnt my goal ^^
 
I said you can't represent Pepsi by displaying a picture with all of their employees in it.
Personal≠ Professional.
You also did not read the original post, which specifically mentioned the fact that there is no trailer currently.
We will be adding drawn graphics to the OneChannel background, so you're right on the money there.
TBH if you actually were to analyse it, you would see that the font used is customised, there is a subtle blur effect on the strapline, even the smoke has added lens flair and hue adjustment layers.
This post brought to you by the Passive Aggressive Association Of North North Americania.
 
As i've said my goal was not to get under your skin which seems to be aggrivating the case more than subtling it out. You said and i quote : "What do you guys think? What would you change?" I gave you my honnest impression trying to fill it with constructive critiscism. I got the fact you don't have a trailer, I was tossing you out tips about making one that would be interesting and professionnal at the same time. But it seems every time i respond back i just p**s you off more.

As for the work put into the banner, customize font is great... but everything else is done in photoshop in those 20min. Anyway in the end its your channel do as you please with it but going around asking for input and then getting all defensive about criticism you receive... i find it very petty. However i'll leave it to this, best of luck in your endeavors.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top