New Channel Thumbnail (Looking For Feedback)

[Marcan3308]

I recently changed my thumbnail to something a little cleaner and more professional. Just wondering if it's something I should stick with (on the right) or if the old thumbnail (on the left) is better. Thanks in advance!

 

[Flammy]

I like the right one more because it is much cleaner looking.

 

[Camille Montpetit]

I prefer the simple one. The other one has just too much stuff going on and yeah...its just too much for my eyeballs.

 

[Ragingkittycat]

Look's epic I really like it.

 

[Opticgeekify]

I like the one on the right , the one of the left just looks a bit messy. And in thumbnail size it would look a bit funny!

 

[SubjectSarah]

I really love the one on the right- the shading and highlighting is beautiful!!! Very nice work!!!