Discuss Symph Reviews

[Symph]

Ok, I don't know if the mods and everyone will be on board with my idea, but I think it's necessary. There is a reason I said I didn't want banter in my review thread. When I let my old thread just go, many people told me how annoying it was looking for my reviews amongst a sea of non related comments or even just comments about my reviews. They just wanted to see my reviews. That's why I want the Symph's Private Review threads free of all commentary on my reviews, some of you are doing it anyway because you don't see the big deal and I get that, at this level it's NOT a big deal, but it could easily escalate into one as people become more and more used to seeing commentary in that thread. This isn't me trying to avoid critiques of my reviews, so the best solution I could think of, was making this thread. The "Review the Reviewer" thread. If you'd like to talk about one of my reviews, why you thought it sucked, why you thought it was great etc, please do so here. Here we can discuss them all day long, I just want the actual review thread, neat, concise, and easy to browse. I don't want people to have to wade through comments to find the reviews. If a mod could sticky this, I'd love that, but I don't know if you'll consider it important enough.

 

[Stef]

I think it's a good idea I just...I didn't see a big deal with the comments in your first thread besides that time when a big 'fight' broke out and things did get a bit confusing.

 

[Symph]

I think it's a good idea I just...I didn't see a big deal with the comments in your first thread besides that time when a big 'fight' broke out and things did get a bit confusing.

Just because my reviews are private, doesn't mean they aren't the same reviews, feelings can still get hurt, and people could still want to come vent in that thread, maybe if they know they aren't breaking any rules in this thread, they'll come here instead