Would you pay for a tool That summarises and analyses your comments?

The idea makes sense to me, especially the part about turning thousands of comments into specific, actionable feedback rather than just another sentiment score. The constructive criticism and audience pain points would probably be the most valuable features for me, since those could directly influence future videos. I also like the idea of identifying recurring commenters and potential collaborators, which could be harder to spot manually. The pay-per-video option sounds appealing for smaller creators who may not need continuous analysis. I’d be interested to see how accurately it can separate genuinely useful criticism from simple negativity. https://win-beatz.pl/
 
Hey everyone,

I'm have developed a tool that ingests comments from YouTube (and other platforms like TikTok & Instagram) and generates a report that extracts valuable information from the comments. The idea is to give creators insights into their community without having to manually sift through hundreds or thousands of comments.

While I am now sure it is technically feasible, I want to make sure this is actually valuable and not just a solution searching for a problem.

The main features include:

  1. Summarising constructive criticism – What are people saying you could improve? Includes example comments and actionable advice to improve your content.
  2. Highlighting what people love – What’s resonating with your audience? How can you further this feature of your content?
  3. Auto-moderation – Flagging problematic comments for auto-deletion (harassment, spam, trolls, confrontational), spotting repeat offenders for potential bans.
  4. Community engagement – Identifying high-value commenters, suggesting responses, and flagging influential users who could be potential collaborators.
  5. Understanding audience pain points – What confuses or frustrates your viewers? How can you address it in replies or future content?
  6. Video feedback – Analysing your transcript to suggest clearer phrasing, pacing, or delivery improvements.
  7. Competitor insights – Analysing other creators in your niche to highlight competitive advantages and areas for growth.
Since running this analysis requires an AI model, the service would have to be paid, but it would be relatively inexpensive—either a one-time payment per video (a couple dollars) or a subscription for ongoing channel insights.

If you’re a creator, would this be something you'd pay for? If not, is there anything missing that would make it more useful?

Would love to hear your thoughts!
Honestly, small creators won't pay for this because they read their comments anyway, and big creators already use tools like TubeBuddy or VidIQ.

If you want people to buy it, keep these in mind:

No per-video fees: Pay-per-video ($2-$3) feels annoying. Go for a simple $10–$15/month subscription instead.

Focus on real value: Simple sentiment analysis isn't enough. Double down on Auto-Spam/Bot Deletion and Video Idea Extraction (grouping what viewers are actually asking for).

Add a free trial: Let people test 1 video for free so they can see if the AI insights are actually worth it.

Position it as a time-saver + spam blocker rather than just a comment reader, and you'll have a much better shot.
 
Hi.
I’d consider paying for one if it can turn a large volume of comments into useful patterns without losing the context behind them. For example, creators could use comment trends to understand what people respond to, while musicians can analyze feedback on releases. A quick way to check the tempo of music mentioned in feedback is https://taptempotool.com/.
 
Back
Top