Making money from covers of songs?

UTubeW

Member
Joined
Mar 22, 2013
Messages
8
Reaction score
0
Age
45
When you do a cover of a song, if you don't use the background music of the original song by making your own version of background, even if you sing the song with the same melody and lyrics, the cover doesn't get removed from YouTube in violation of copyright law, since the background music is at least different.

So does that mean that you can monetize the videos of your song covers if your cover of the song gets very popular?
 
Last edited:

The NotARubicon!

NotARubicon Productions
Joined
Mar 3, 2017
Messages
663
Reaction score
328
Location
Southern California
Channel Type
Director
I'm curious to read people's views on this.
I monetize several videos that use covers of very popular songs. I have an agreement with the musician that does the covers, and he has agreements with the record labels/original artists (he has to, he is very big on YT)..
So in my case, i think I'm ok.. but still curious how it all works.
 

KatyAdelson

I Love YTtalk
Staff member
Joined
Mar 13, 2015
Messages
7,166
Reaction score
6,855
Location
Colorado
Channel Type
Musician
If you make your own backing track and recording, it's still under copyright of the original song creator and music producer and you technically need permission from the copyright owners to post a video with your cover.

You risk the video being taken down whenever you do a cover song, but many record labels are tolerant of the videos. Many record labels are NOT tolerant of others monetizing the videos, so I'd be careful about using cover versions of popular songs in your videos. Check through YouTube's music policies to see what the current monetization eligibility status is if you cover a song or use a covered version of a song:
https://www.youtube.com/music_policies

Note that the music policies can change at any time and without warning...thus why I say all cover artists risk their videos being taken down.

Most musicians who cover music are not monetizing their covers on YouTube. If you see ads on the video, there is a high chance that the actual record label is the one that has monetized the video, not the YouTuber. The YouTuber usually gets nothing from their cover from the YouTube platform. The only instance where I've seen musicians actually being paid for their covers is with the well-debated "Nintendo Creators Program." I find it fascinating that what is finally a giant relief and first ability for musicians to be paid at least a tiny bit for making a cover for YouTube is so wildly debated and somewhat boycotted by the gaming YouTubers.

However, if the YouTuber has purchased a Mechanical License, they can distribute their covered version of the song fairly easily on platforms like iTunes so long as they pay royalties for every song purchased. It's possible to still earn money from covered music, but unless it's through Nintendo or a partnership of some sort, it's probably not going to be from YouTube monetization.
 

UTubeW

Member
Joined
Mar 22, 2013
Messages
8
Reaction score
0
Age
45
How do you purchase a Mechanical License? Is it not likely for viewers to actually purchase the covers on iTunes? Since they can just download the music off of YouTube for free with a Firefox add-on?