Anyone tried Xsplit or if not what capture software do you use :)

Ankonite

New Member
Joined
Nov 14, 2017
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Age
37
Location
UK
Channel Type
Youtuber
I use Xsplit for all my video's but i'm curious to see how many people use it and how many people use alternatives. :)
 

Firefang

// Weekly gaming related content //
Joined
Nov 13, 2017
Messages
96
Reaction score
35
Age
25
Location
Belgium
Channel Type
Youtuber
Mhm well Xsplit and OBS I'd only really recommend for streamers. if you're just normally recording gameplay I'd say Shadowplay, as it's performance impact is minimal. Otherwise, fraps, but it hits performance quite heavily so be cautious with it.
 

Switchbox

Give me your food
Joined
Jan 22, 2013
Messages
12,638
Reaction score
5,560
Location
Norway
Channel Type
Youtuber, Vlogger, Gamer, Commentator, Other
Mhm well Xsplit and OBS I'd only really recommend for streamers. if you're just normally recording gameplay I'd say Shadowplay, as it's performance impact is minimal. Otherwise, fraps, but it hits performance quite heavily so be cautious with it.
Something odd happened to me. I was trying to record Skyward Sword on an emulator, and OBS made the FPS drop like crazy, while if I used Fraps it was buttery smooth lol
 

Kevin Muldoon

Loving YTtalk
Joined
Feb 25, 2015
Messages
250
Reaction score
72
Channel Type
Reviewer
I connect my cameras and record regular videos using OBS (and stream too). You can set the frame rate, resolution, and bit rate.

I really wanted to like XSplit but it kept crashing on me. I'm so used to OBS now that I'm not sure I'd want to change.

Sent from my HTC U11 using Tapatalk
 

MrRwstudios

Active Member
Joined
Jul 31, 2015
Messages
29
Reaction score
2
Channel Type
Gamer
I frequently use OBS for streaming, but I use NVIDIA Share (Shadowplay) for recording PC Gameplay and Elgato Game Capture for console.

However, Shadowplay is only available to people with modern NVIDIA brand GPUs. So if you don't have that I'd recommend FRAPS or Bandicam.

And the Elgato device itself is costly, but is definitely worth it for capturing console gameplay.
 

TheScarletBlaze

YTtalk Mad
Joined
Jul 27, 2014
Messages
319
Reaction score
97
Age
27
Location
Essex
Channel Type
Vlogger
I use OBS for the most Part i used to Use Xsplit but i was not happy with the Quality i got, Also used to Use Shadowplay which is by far the highest quality one i have used, however the file size is stupendous
 

Shehzad

The Brown Fudge
Joined
Dec 14, 2015
Messages
788
Reaction score
292
Age
27
Channel Type
Gamer
OBS is a great tool for recording, it is not just for streaming! It has all the options that will enable you to do just as much and more. It is very versatile in the fact that you can use the advanced settings - which allows you to change your birate and quality control settings to tune the output quality just how you would want it. It by far outshines software like fraps and bandicam due to the simple fact that It offers you much more control for your video, it's also free and the quality is miles better anyway. I would highly recommend watching tutorials on how to configure OBS as a little work for great quality is not asking for much. You can set up a lot of templates as well, for example you can have a streaming profile and a recording profile so you do not have to constantly change your settings. You can set up scenes and bind them to keys to change through them live or during your recording (similar to xsplit). The only reason I do not use xsplit even though it is actually a very good piece of software is that a lot of it's features are hidden behind the subscription you have to pay for unlike OBS where you get it all. People even make custom plugins for you to use for OBS. I've used xsplit, dxtory, bandicam, fraps you name it and I have settled for OBS after many years of using the other software. Be careful though OBS can be CPU intensive (as with most recording software) depending on how much bitrate (quality) you want to allow the software to control - i.e higher bitrate = more load on CPU & bigger file sizes. You can use the NVENC settings if you have a decent Nvidia GPU to lighten the load on you CPU. Modern games tend to use less CPU power so you have the option of x264(CPU) or Nvidia NVENC (GPU) settings to meet your needs. Also I'd use OBS multiplatform instead of the standard OBS as it gives you more options for example I have a mixer and a virtual mixer too and It allows me to control the settings In tandem with my mixer to individually set my game audio, discord audio and windows audio to control the audio tracks separately as well as much more but that is by far taking it to the advanced stages. You have great options to set up filters for your microphone like a noise gate or compression to eliminate background noise, this is really scratching the tip of the iceberg. In my opinion what you get from OBS is well worth it.





Shadowplay is also an all round nice software for recording, very easy to use and the quality is really nice. I use this if am casually gaming and I need to record something on the fly very quickly instead of opening up OBS all the time (though you could keep OBS running all times in case of these situations and just bind a key to start recording when the need arises). If your someone who just wants something intuitive and stress free without much work then use shadowplay It's not so in your face with all the different settings and works well out of the box. Only problem is It is only for Nvidia
GPU's as far as am aware.

Just remember YT will compress your video quality down anyway so use the bitrate during post editing that youtube recommends for videos. Type in recommended upload settings for youtube on google to get to that page.

Keep them In mind during post


[DOUBLEPOST=1511751702,1511751045][/DOUBLEPOST]
Something odd happened to me. I was trying to record Skyward Sword on an emulator, and OBS made the FPS drop like crazy, while if I used Fraps it was buttery smooth lol
Emulators use a lot of CPU power and software like OBS does too so combining the two it is no wonder you are getting frame drops. Fraps gives you less quality output then OBS so It would use much less CPU usage that is why It was smooth. I'd drop the quality control on OBS if you wanted it to work with an emulator am guessing your CPU cannot handle the load.
 
Last edited:

Ankonite

New Member
Joined
Nov 14, 2017
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Age
37
Location
UK
Channel Type
Youtuber
i tried obs and yer i do like it but i prefer Xsplit really. just maybe because im more used to it.