Thank you so much! I appreciate this feedback so much. Especially the bit of trying to get out of my comfort zone. I think I get so stuck in a comfortable way of doing things that I don't want to switch it up -- and you're right!!!
Again, thank you!
Yeah, I'm experimenting a lot last few months, changing the content delivery, video structure and I also recently switched to a new thumbnail pattern. The views seem to be increasingy, very, very slowly, but it's tough to say how much of that incremental growth is simply due to more people actively playing D&D nowadays compared to back in 2018, when I started the channel.
Based on my interpretation of my analytics data, it seems like watchtime is a key component for achieving micro/mini/semi-viral effects, specifically views from YT Homepage beyond the 48 hour mark after the video has been uploaded.
However, in order to get people to watch your videos for 5,6, 7 or more minutes on average, you have to do so many things right and everything has to fall into place almost perfectly. 15-20 minute long videos seem to be the safest bet, unless you can somehow get people to watch like 80-90% of a 10 minute long video - I'm beyond happy if my videos get just half of that percentage to be honest. Anything below 10% CTR will kill the virality sooner rather than later, because the video simply isn't getting enough views every hour to accumulate watchtime. And no amounts of watchtime, CTR and views seem to be matter in the long run when you get just 27 likes and 3 comments in the first 2-3 days.
Breaking into Suggested/Recommended traffic category for a consistent stream of views every day is still a mystery to me, even though all these YT "gurus" make it seem so easy. I have yet to get 1 video to get any meaningful traffic from suggestions, save a random click here and there.
Ranking videos in YT search is still relatively easy, though you have to go for stuff that doesn't have a lot of competition, otherwise nobody will ever find you no matter what combination of keywords they type into the search bar